Yahoo Finance Young couple earns $186K/year but child care eats up most of the wife’s paycheck — should she just stay home?
Amanda and Carlos, a young couple with two small children, have been together for seven years but are still trying to find a way to marry their financial philosophies.
Carlos describes Amanda’s attitude about money as “complacent,” while he himself is very worried about money — and specifically the right things to do with it.
Don't miss
These 5 magic money moves will boost you up America's net worth ladder in 2024 — and you can complete each step within minutes. Here's how
'You didn't want to risk it': 80-year-old woman from South Carolina is looking for the safest place for her family's $250,000 savings. Here's Dave Ramsey's response
Car insurance premiums in America are through the roof — and only getting worse. But 5 minutes could have you paying as little as $29/month
Now they’re at a crossroads in their financial lives, as they told Ramit Sethi on a recent episode of his podcast. They’re technically in pretty decent shape financially, with a solid household income and an accurate sense of their numbers. Amanda had been a stay-at-home parent, and went back to work to earn a little extra money. But she’s now finding the exorbitant cost of child care “a bittersweet pill to swallow.”
“We see how much we're paying for daycare. What was the point of going back to work when my whole salary is basically gone at the end of the month?” she said.
This family’s situation is becoming increasingly common as the costs of raising children escalate rapidly.
Difficult decision
Sethi sympathizes with their situation.
“[Child care] is such a difficult topic for parents across America,” Sethi says. And it’s only become more challenging as the price of it has exploded in recent years. The cost of daycare and preschool rose 263% from 1990 to April 2024, according to a report by KPMG. That’s faster than the pace of inflation over the same period.
As of 2024, the average weekly cost of daycare is $321 per child, according to Care.com. Meanwhile, average weekly earnings in the first quarter of 2024 for full-time and salary workers were $1,143, according to the Bureau of Labor Statistics. That means many working parents — especially those with multiple children — may find their child care takes up a significant portion of their paycheck. And the proportion could be much higher if the couple has more than one child or if one partner works part-time or earns less than average.
As a teacher, Amanda earns $4,487 after taxes every month, while the cost of their childrens’ daycare is $1,881. Taking that cost entirely out of her pay would mean 41.9% of her after-tax income goes to child care, which has compelled her to consider giving up her career and staying at home.
However, Sethi believes the decision to drop out of the workforce shouldn’t be taken lightly.
“Child care is one of a handful of times where couples really sit down and look at the numbers, and too often they conclude that financially speaking, one partner would be giving their entire paycheck to daycare,” he says. “So the conclusion is it’s better for that parent to stay home, and in two-parent households that's almost always mom.”
According to a Pew Research Center’s analysis of U.S. Census Bureau data, in 2021, 26% of mothers were stay-at-home parents, compared to only 7% of dads.
However, Sethi says this decision to stay at home is often reflexive and not well-planned. “Parents rarely talk about what this means for her career down the road, or how expenses will be split up or how discretionary expenses should be handled,” he says.
Read more: Berkshire icon Charlie Munger believed homeownership is for families who want to live in them — not single people. Here’s how to invest in real estate no matter your marital status
The cost of staying at home
A study that followed baby boomer women from their 20s to 50s found that women with children were less likely to work, and that working mothers earned lower wages — a “penalty” of 3% to 5% per year — compared to those without children.
However, this gap closed by the time women reached their 40s and 50s, except among mothers with more than three children, who were presumably in the parenting trenches for longer. Other studies have found significant decreases in lifetime earnings for women with children, and the difference is greater the more children there are in the family.
Despite these costs, parents who choose to stay at home to care for children should have a conversation about how household expenses and discretionary spending is split between partners, Sethi says. And it should be a choice they make together rather than the default option.
As for Amanda and Carlos, they’re on the same page about what they want their “rich life” to look like, but they feel they must make sacrifices now — like having Amanda work when they’d both prefer for her to be able to stay home with their kids.
Sethi challenges them to “just play it out” and see what their lives might look like without Amanda’s income. They might have to cut back on some items, like Carlo’s $200 monthly budget for shoes, but even the exercise of talking it through can help get them aligned on their next steps.
Carlos feels strongly the best option for their financial future is for Amanda to keep working, but after seeing how it would actually impact their monthly numbers and how much Amanda wants to be at home, he tells her he’s open to the discussion. These types of talks, Sethi says, are the only way they’re going to achieve their rich life.
“The work versus stay at home decision is much more complex than [just money.] But what’s really important for them is to really ask each other: What do we want for this life? Let’s get honest with each other and look at the numbers too. Can we make it happen in some form?”
What to read next
Thanks to Jeff Bezos, you can now use $100 to cash in on prime real estate — without the headache of being a landlord. Here's how
Stop crushing your retirement dreams with wealth-killing costs and headaches — here are 10 'must-haves' when choosing a trading platform (and 1 option that has them all)
Don’t leave your family unprotected — find life insurance coverage up to $2 million with no medical exam or blood test
This article provides information only and should not be construed as advice. It is provided without warranty of any kind.
