Canada Markets open in 8 hrs 34 mins

Tesla Stock Drops, Wiping Out Elon Musk's Twitter-Fueled 'Going Private' Rally

Bloomberg

It didn’t take long for the euphoria to fade.

Two days after Elon Musk triggered a frantic rally with a tweet saying he was considering taking Tesla tsla private, the stock erased all of those gains.

Doubts have mounted about Musk’s ability to take the electric-car maker off the market, sending the stock tumbling 4.8% to $352.45 on Thursday, well off the $420 at which Musk said shareholders would be bought out. The shares have dropped on back-to-back days after jumping 11% on Tuesday, when Musk vowed that he had “funding secured” at a spectacular $82 billion valuation.

Since that initial tweet, Musk has offered no evidence to back up the statement. Nor has anyone stepped forward publicly—or privately—to say they’re behind the plan. People with or close to 15 financial institutions and technology firms who spoke on the condition of anonymity said they weren’t aware of financing having been locked in before Musk’s posts.

“I don’t really understand the idea of what was suggested in the potential for them to go private,” Dick Weil, chief executive officer of $370 billion asset manager Janus Henderson Group, said in an interview with Bloomberg Television. “That’s obviously an incredibly large valuation to somehow take into the private market.”

The dearth of details could be problematic. The Securities and Exchange Commission already had been gathering general information about Tesla’s public pronouncements regarding manufacturing goals and sales targets, according to two people who asked not to be named because the review is private.Now, the attorneys are also examining whether Musk’s tweet about having funding to buy out the company was meant to be factual, according to one of the people.

“When Musk tweeted this, was he saying this was something that was definitely going to happen? Something that might happen?” said Ira Matetsky, a partner at Ganfer Shore Leeds & Zauderer in New York. “How would a reasonable investor interpret that and was it consistent with the facts as they existed at the time?”

Judith Burns, an SEC spokeswoman, declined to comment. Tesla, which hasn’t been accused of wrongdoing, declined to comment.

‘I Wish’

Musk had first raised the go-private possibility with the board last week, according to a statement from six of Tesla’s nine directors. They said he had “addressed the funding for this to occur,” without providing details.

As for Tesla shareholders, Musk said in one of his Twitter posts that “investor support is confirmed” for his plan. The company’s largest shareholders have declined to comment. A spokeswoman for the California State Teachers’ Retirement System, which held about 279,000 shares as of the end of June, said there was no heads-up given.

“We have not been contacted by Tesla IR,” said Michelle Mussuto, the spokeswoman. “They didn’t reach out before the tweet either.”

Leaving the public marketplace isn’t a new vision for Musk. “I wish we could be private with Tesla,” he told Rolling Stone in an interview published in November. “It actually makes us less efficient to be a public company.”

In April 2017, when Musk held talks with Masayoshi Son about SoftBank Group Corp. investing in the electric carmaker, they touched on the possibility of fulfilling Musk’s wish, according to two people with knowledge of the discussions. The talks failed to progress due to disagreements over ownership and have not started up again.

Musk’s personal stake in Tesla is almost 20%, meaning he would need roughly $70 billion to take it out of the market. That kind of money may be accessible through sovereign wealth funds or other strategic investors, said Dwight Scott, president of Blackstone Group LP’s GSO Capital Partners. The money-losing and cash-burning company is an unlikely candidate for debt investors to be willing to help go private.

It’s possible Musk could persuade some large institutional and strategic investors to either newly become or remain shareholders in the private company, which could reduce his funding needs, said Toni Sacconaghi, an analyst at Bernstein who has long been bearish on Tesla shares.

But “if no firmer details emerge,” he wrote in a report to clients, “investors would likely increasingly debate Musk’s credibility and seemingly unhealthy focus on the shares’ price and volatility.”

It’s also possible Musk has some unconventional plan that would take Tesla private without using traditional sources. On Twitter, he alluded to the creation of a “special purpose fund enabling anyone to stay with Tesla.”

Read more: How SpaceX may be a road map for Tesla going private

Morgan Stanley analyst Adam Jonas said investors would be slow to forgive if no buyout transpires.

“A failed attempt at a deal would create new challenges for Tesla as a stand-alone public company,” wrote Jonas, who rates the stock the equivalent of hold. “It may be challenging for Tesla shareholders to fathom the ‘forget-about-the-going-private-thing-let’s-go-back-to-normal’ scenario.”

Tesla’s Potential Take-Private Coverage: In the wake of Musk’s tweet, more questions than answers Meet the Tesla board being tested like never before SEC review of Musk tweets likely to focus on truthfulness Musk is said to have discussed investment with SoftBank’s Son Dell’s lesson for Tesla: going private isn’t a cure-all.

  • Melinda Gates speaks on smoothing the shift to digital age
    Finance
    The Canadian Press

    Melinda Gates speaks on smoothing the shift to digital age

    Instead of destroying jobs and leaving legions of people without work, the digital revolution can open doors to unseen opportunities and industries, but only if everyone has access to the internet and the ability to use it, Melinda Gates said in a recent interview with The Associated Press. The Bill

  • China economic growth slips to weakest since 2009, demand ebbs as trade war bites
    Finance
    Reuters

    China economic growth slips to weakest since 2009, demand ebbs as trade war bites

    Chinese authorities are trying to navigate through numerous challenges, as the trade war fears have sparked a blistering selloff in domestic stock markets and a steep decline in the value of the yuan versus the dollar, heightening worries about the growth outlook. The economy grew 6.5 percent in the

  • Asia Stocks Fall; China Erases Drop After Support: Markets Wrap
    Finance
    Bloomberg

    Asia Stocks Fall; China Erases Drop After Support: Markets Wrap

    China’s equities reversed losses after verbal intervention by the nation’s top financial regulators, who assured they’ll keep financial risks under control. China’s Shanghai Composite remained near a four-year low. China’s recent rout spurred the most explicit comments by policy makers to date, with

  • It's a Long Way Down for China Stocks Channeling Past Traumas
    Finance
    Bloomberg

    It's a Long Way Down for China Stocks Channeling Past Traumas

    Private companies are struggling with liquidity concerns, the economic outlook is slowing as a trade war with the U.S. deepens, and a weakening yuan is starting to prompt capital outflows. “The time when the the market is going to turn around has to be reasonably soon, but I don’t think anybody knows

  • China's Economy Slows Amid Darker Outlook at Home and Abroad
    Finance
    Bloomberg

    China's Economy Slows Amid Darker Outlook at Home and Abroad

    Gross domestic product increased 6.5 percent in the three months through September from a year earlier, compared to 6.6 percent in a Bloomberg survey and down from the 6.7 percent pace in the previous quarter. The economy has faced increasing headwinds this year, with worsening trade tensions and a

  • Here's the Asia Stocks Verdict: Bulls Are Missing in Action
    Finance
    Bloomberg

    Here's the Asia Stocks Verdict: Bulls Are Missing in Action

    While Asia now boasts the lowest stock valuations since February 2016 -- shares in the MSCI Asia Pacific Index trade at 11.7 times estimated earnings for the next year -- the benchmark gauge was down 0.7 percent by 12 p.m. in Hong Kong, heading for a fourth straight week of declines. Japanese shares

  • Exxon Exploration Chief Eyes Africa for Elephant Oil Find
    Finance
    Bloomberg

    Exxon Exploration Chief Eyes Africa for Elephant Oil Find

    The oil supermajor “really loaded” its exploration portfolio recently by purchasing large positions in Ghana, Mauritania, South Africa and Namibia, as well as Cyprus and Malaysia as rivals pulled back, Stephen Greenlee, Exxon’s president of exploration, said in an interview in Houston. Exxon’s buying

  • Suddenly Toxic, Saudi Prince Is Shunned by Investors He Courted
    Finance
    Bloomberg

    Suddenly Toxic, Saudi Prince Is Shunned by Investors He Courted

    Now Crown Prince Mohammed bin Salman could become the biggest risk to his own project. Everything changed when Jamal Khashoggi walked into the Saudi consulate in Istanbul on Oct. 2 and didn’t come out. Prince Mohammed, who’s denied any knowledge of Khashoggi’s fate, still has his defenders -– notably

  • Bullish Insiders Snap Up Their Companies' Stocks as Others Flee
    Finance
    Bloomberg

    Bullish Insiders Snap Up Their Companies' Stocks as Others Flee

    “When the buy-sell ratio is three, it’s astonishing,” said Patrick Hable, a Frankfurt-based managing partner at the data provider. Top-level managers’ share purchases in companies they work for are a good sign, showing that those with superior knowledge of the business find the stock cheap. The buy-sell

  • China Urges Investor Calm While Stopping Short of Market Rescue
    Finance
    Bloomberg

    China Urges Investor Calm While Stopping Short of Market Rescue

    The statements from heads of China’s central bank, securities watchdog and banking and insurance regulator -- which promised measures to help ease financial pressures on companies -- underscored the growing sense of panic among investors after the country’s $3 trillion stock rout accelerated this week

  • Japan's Inflation Creeps Up Again, Fueled by Energy Prices
    Finance
    Bloomberg

    Japan's Inflation Creeps Up Again, Fueled by Energy Prices

    While Kuroda has taken a more bullish view on the current strength in inflation, economists said the latest data offered little beyond the gains in energy and food prices to suggest that inflation can make major progress in the near term. Energy prices rose 8.1 percent from a year earlier, contributing

  • Man Who Bared `Enigma Network' Has New Hong Kong Stock Alert
    Finance
    Bloomberg

    Man Who Bared `Enigma Network' Has New Hong Kong Stock Alert

    Now David Webb, the activist investor and resident gadfly of Hong Kong’s capital markets, is at it again. In a post on his website Friday, Webb published a list of 26 stocks “not to own” due to links with China Huarong Asset Management Co., the bad-debt management firm whose former chairman is under

  • China's economic growth slows amid trade battle with US
    Finance
    The Canadian Press

    China's economic growth slows amid trade battle with US

    China's economic growth decelerated further in the latest quarter, adding to challenges for communist leaders as they fight a tariff battle with Washington. The world's second-largest economy expanded by 6.5 per cent over a year earlier in the three months ending in September, government data

  • Finance
    The Canadian Press

    Australia lawyers' group: Draft cyber laws would curb rights

    The president of Australia's top lawyers' group told a parliamentary inquiry that proposed cybersecurity laws to force global technology companies such as Facebook and Google to help police by unscrambling encrypted messages sent by extremists and other criminals would significantly limit individuals

  • Asia shares slide further as weak China growth adds to woes
    Finance
    Reuters

    Asia shares slide further as weak China growth adds to woes

    The MSCI's broadest index of Asia-Pacific shares outside Japan was 0.2 percent weaker following China's latest GDP reading. Australian shares fell 0.3 percent and Japan's Nikkei average was 1.1 percent lower. "Markets continue to digest the combination of higher U.S. rates, ongoing

  • Finance
    Bloomberg

    China Electric Scooter Maker Raises $63 Million in Downsized IPO

    The Beijing-based company sold 7 million American depositary shares at $9 apiece, it said in a statement dated Thursday, confirming an earlier Bloomberg News report. Niu had been marketing a sale of 8.3 million shares at $9 to $10 apiece, after initially offering them at $10.50 to $12.50 each. Niu’

  • Eurodollar Futures Volume Heaviest Since Election Day 2016
    Finance
    Bloomberg

    Eurodollar Futures Volume Heaviest Since Election Day 2016

    It was the rate’s biggest jump since May. That followed Wednesday’s release of minutes of the Federal Open Market Committee’s Sept. 26 meeting, which dimmed expectations for another adjustment to the interest on excess reserves rate in December. Initial release of positioning data showed open positions

  • Pressure turns to Mexico as migrant caravan heads for border
    Finance
    The Canadian Press

    Pressure turns to Mexico as migrant caravan heads for border

    As some 3,000 Hondurans made their way through Guatemala, attention turned to Mexico, after U.S. President Donald Trump threatened Thursday to close the U.S.-Mexico border if authorities there fail to stop them — a nearly unthinkable move that would disrupt hundreds of thousands of legal freight, vehicle

  • Indonesia Corruption Crackdown Adds to Strains on Junk Bonds
    Finance
    Bloomberg

    Indonesia Corruption Crackdown Adds to Strains on Junk Bonds

    “There could be broader implications as it brings the question over corporate governance into focus again,” said Charles Macgregor, head of emerging markets at Lucror Analytics Pte in Singapore. Indonesian dollar junk bonds have lost 6 percent this year, compared with the average 2.8 percent decline

  • China third quarter GDP growth slows to 6.5 percent year-on-year, missing forecast
    Finance
    Reuters

    China third quarter GDP growth slows to 6.5 percent year-on-year, missing forecast

    China's economy grew at a slower than expected pace of 6.5 percent in the third quarter from a year earlier, marking the weakest rate since the global financial crisis, official data showed on Friday. The data points to a modest cooling in the world's second-largest economy, as the government

  • SAP's Russell Says 'Proud' of Performance of Asia Pacific
    Finance
    Bloomberg

    SAP's Russell Says 'Proud' of Performance of Asia Pacific

    Oct.18 -- Scott Russell, president for Asia Pacific Japan at SAP, talks about the company's performance in the region. Europe’s biggest technology company raised its projections for the year due to accelerating momentum for its cloud business, but third quarter profit missed analyst estimates. Russell

  • Oil prices edge up, but set for weekly loss on stock build, trade row
    Finance
    Reuters

    Oil prices edge up, but set for weekly loss on stock build, trade row

    Front-month London Brent crude for December delivery was up 34 cents, or 0.4 percent, at $79.63 a barrel. "EIA Weekly Petroleum Status Report was a complete shocker sending Oil markets spiraling lower amidst some concerning development for Oil bulls," said Stephen Innes, head of trading APAC

  • Tesla launches new $45,000 Model 3
    Finance
    Reuters

    Tesla launches new $45,000 Model 3

    Tesla Inc on Thursday introduced a new $45,000 version of its Model 3 sedan on its website, launching the car as U.S. tax breaks for Tesla cars are about to decrease. The tax credit for Tesla cars will drop by half on Jan. 1. Although Tesla has promised a base-level version of the Model 3 priced at

  • The Latest: UN expert: Government abductions are new worry
    Finance
    The Canadian Press

    The Latest: UN expert: Government abductions are new worry

    A U.N. expert says the world is witnessing "a new and very worrisome practice" of governments abducting people in foreign countries using undercover operations, citing the case of missing Saudi journalist Jamal Khashoggi. Duhaime reiterated a call for an independent international investigation

  • The Biggest Companies at Risk as China's Margin Calls Increase
    Finance
    Bloomberg

    The Biggest Companies at Risk as China's Margin Calls Increase

    It’s a risk at the top of investors’ minds in China after the nation’s $3 trillion equity rout deepened on Thursday, driving the Shanghai Composite Index to a nearly four-year low. With more than $600 billion of Chinese shares pledged as collateral for loans, or about 11 percent of the country’s market