Canada Markets closed

Lululemon files lawsuit against Ross Stores over 'lowest-quality' knock-off leggings

Washington DC: Lululemon building exterior with woman entering store by sign.

Lululemon Athletica Inc. (LULU) has filed a lawsuit against Ross Stores Inc. (ROST) and one of its suppliers for allegedly selling “the lowest-quality” counterfeit versions of the company’s leggings.

The Vancouver-based apparel company filed the lawsuit in the U.S. Northern District of California last month, alleging claims of trademark infringement, counterfeiting, and unfair competition against Ross Stores and Impulse Off Price Apparel (IOPA), a California apparel supplier.

According to the complaint, Ross Stores and IOPA “distributed and sold at least thousands of counterfeit Lululemon products to consumers and retailers” that Lululemon claims were “of a quality substantially and materially inferior” to its genuine products.

“These counterfeit sales have resulted in consumer confusion and significantly harmed Lululemon and the consumer goodwill associated with the Lululemon brand,” the lawsuit said.

‘Among the lowest-quality’ leggings

Lululemon representatives purchased 20 pairs of counterfeit leggings in March from two California locations of Dd’s Discounts, a chain owned by Ross Stores, the complaint says. Lululemon attached photos of the alleged counterfeit designs, which included tags that mimic the company’s authentic versions and state that the product was designed in Vancouver. Dd’s Discounts was allegedly selling the leggings for $7.99 – $120.01 less than the retail price of the authentic versions.

Lululemon alleges that counterfeit versions of its leggings, featuring replica tags that say the products were made in Vancouver, were being sold by Ross Stores.

“Lululemon analyzed the counterfeit products and determined they were among the lowest-quality counterfeit leggings that Lululemon had ever encountered,” the lawsuit said. According to the complaint, Lululemon’s authentic leggings are typically made of “smooth, four-way stretch... quick-drying, sweat-wicking fabric.” The counterfeit products, on the other hand, “were made of thin, cheap polyester blends and were not constructed with the high-quality details found in genuine Lululemon products.”

Lululemon sells its products exclusively through its bricks-and-mortar stores and e-commerce website, as well as through partnerships with premium yoga studios, gyms and wellness centres. The company alleged that given “it is well known” that Lululemon does not sell its products through discount retailers, Ross Stores and IOPA were either aware or wilfully blind to the authenticity of the products being sold.

In the lawsuit, Lululemon also included social media posts that it said showed consumers have been confused by the counterfeit products.

“The harm to Lululemon’s brand and goodwill caused by (the) defendants’ conduct is ongoing, as the negative reviews continue to mount, and confirm the confusion and disappointment caused to consumers due to the inferior quality of the counterfeit “Lululemon” branded goods sold by (the) defendants,” the lawsuit alleges.

Lululemon is seeking the destruction of any and all products that infringe the company’s trademarks, as well as damages and profits attributable to the alleged sales.

Ross Stores and IOPA filed a motion requesting an extension of time to file a response, which was initially due on July 15 and 16. The order was granted and the defendants must file a response on or before August 15.

Ross Stores has not responded to a request for comment as of Monday.

This is not the first time Lululemon has gone to court over trademark infringement and concerns about counterfeit products.

In a complaint filed with the United States District Court in Illinois in February, Lululemon alleged that a list of defendants are selling counterfeit knockoffs online, which has caused the company to be “irreparably damaged through consumer confusion, dilution and tarnishment of its valuable trademarks.” Lululemon alleged the individuals and businesses selling counterfeit products resided in China “or other foreign jurisdictions.”

In April, Lululemon won a default judgement as the defendants failed to respond to Lululemon’s complaint. Judge Gary Feinerman ordered the defendants to stop using Lululemon trademarks and have the website domains either be transferred to Lululemon’s control or shutdown. He also ordered the defendants to pay Lululemon $200,000 in statutory damages.

Yahoo Finance Canada

Download the Yahoo Finance app, available for Apple and Android.

  • Finance
    The Canadian Press

    Alaska bars, breweries propose bill rewriting alcohol laws

    JUNEAU, Alaska — An agreement was reached over drinks between a bar association and a brewing association in Alaska that could rewrite alcohol laws and change how people enjoy their beverages across the state.The agreement produced a bill that would bring changes for brewery, winery and distillery tasting

  • Finance
    Bloomberg

    U.S. Raises Japan Warning; Italy Issues Travel Ban: Virus Update

    (Bloomberg) -- The U.S. raised its travel warning to Japan -– more evidence of the fear of the coronavirus’s spread and that the window to stop a global pandemic is closing.Iran, Italy and South Korea reported new deaths Saturday. In total, there are some 77,000 cases worldwide, with over 2,300 deaths

  • Globalization Comes Under Fire Amid Coronavirus ‘Stress Test’
    Finance
    Bloomberg

    Globalization Comes Under Fire Amid Coronavirus ‘Stress Test’

    (Bloomberg) -- Terms of Trade is a daily newsletter that untangles a world threatened by trade wars. Sign up here. Finance chiefs from the world’s largest economies are realizing the coronavirus isn’t just a short-term threat to global growth – it’s exposing the vulnerabilities of globalization itself.As

  • Finance
    The Canadian Press

    Education group lawsuit accuses ex-leader of stealing $200K

    ANCHORAGE, Alaska — An educational organization that promotes the oil, gas, mining and timber industries in Alaska has sued its former executive director, accusing her of stealing more than $200,000.Alaska Resource Education filed the civil complaint Wednesday in U.S. District Court in Alaska against

  • U.S. Raises Japan Warning as Infections Spread: Virus Update
    Finance
    Bloomberg

    U.S. Raises Japan Warning as Infections Spread: Virus Update

    (Bloomberg) -- The U.S. raised its travel warning to Japan as Iran, Italy and South Korea all reported additional deaths from the coronavirus.The spread of the virus outside its origin in China stoked fear that the window to prevent a pandemic may be closing. The World Health Organization, which has

  • Trump campaign, Republicans spent over $1 million at Trump businesses in 2019
    Finance
    Yahoo Finance

    Trump campaign, Republicans spent over $1 million at Trump businesses in 2019

    Trump's campaign and Republicans spent big at Trump businesses in 2019.

  • Finance
    The Canadian Press

    US drops plan to sell leases near famed Utah bike trail

    SALT LAKE CITY — U.S. officials have dropped plans to sell energy leases in a popular Utah recreational area that's renowned for its mountain biking trails.The reversal by the U.S. Bureau of Land Management comes after local businesses, officials and Gov. Gary Herbert raised concerns about potential

  • Finance
    Bloomberg

    Brazil’s Best Stock Has Credit Suisse Predicting More Gains

    (Bloomberg) -- The rally in Via Varejo SA shares still has some juice left as the Brazilian retailer’s turnaround initiatives start to bear fruit, according to Credit Suisse.Fourth-quarter adjusted Ebitda margin will expand to 4.6% from 3.7% a year earlier, analysts Victor Saragiotto and Pedro Pinto

  • Iran Hardliners Take Broad Lead in Election as Moderates Stymied
    Finance
    Bloomberg

    Iran Hardliners Take Broad Lead in Election as Moderates Stymied

    (Bloomberg) -- Iranian hard-liners headed for victory in parliamentary elections, sweeping Tehran and other cities in a repudiation of President Hassan Rouhani’s engagement with outside powers.The vote was widely predicted to hand control of the legislature to conservatives empowered by the country’s

  • Finance
    Bloomberg

    Cash-Rich Berkshire Embraces the Idea of Life After Buffett

    (Bloomberg) -- Warren Buffett waited until the very last page of his annual shareholder letter to reveal a big change: Shareholders will be hearing more from top lieutenants Ajit Jain and Greg Abel.The pair, seen as the top contenders to eventually replace Berkshire Hathaway Inc.’s 89-year-old chief

  • At Paris farm fair, Macron vows to protect EU ag subsidies
    Finance
    The Canadian Press

    At Paris farm fair, Macron vows to protect EU ag subsidies

    PARIS — French President Emmanuel Macron reaffirmed his support for maintaining the European Union's farm subsidies at their current level Saturday while attending an agriculture fair that a fixture in French politics.Macron defended the EU's system of agricultural subsidies - a major source

  • Buffett says Wall Street advice usually favours more deals
    Finance
    The Canadian Press

    Buffett says Wall Street advice usually favours more deals

    OMAHA, Neb. — Taking advice from Wall Street on deals is a bit like asking “the barber whether you need a haircut,” according to billionaire Warren Buffett.Buffett said in his annual letter to Berkshire Hathaway shareholders Saturday that the current system of reviewing deals doesn't always work

  • Finance
    The Canadian Press

    Debris found in fuel tanks of 70% of inspected 737 Max jets

    CHICAGO — Debris has been found in the fuel tanks of 70% of grounded Boeing 737 Max jets that have been inspected by the company, Boeing confirmed on Saturday.Inspectors found the debris in 35 out of about 50 jets that were inspected. They are among 400 built in the past year that Boeing hasn't been

  • Buffett Touts Wind Energy Following Climate-Change Criticism
    Finance
    Bloomberg

    Buffett Touts Wind Energy Following Climate-Change Criticism

    (Bloomberg) -- Warren Buffett, long under pressure from activists to detail how climate change affects his businesses, used part of his annual letter to shareholders to highlight how wind power generated by a Berkshire Hathaway Inc. utility shows the company is reducing its reliance on fossil fuels.Buffett

  • The XFL may pull off something no league has before, but week 3 is critical
    Finance
    Yahoo Finance

    The XFL may pull off something no league has before, but week 3 is critical

    The XFL has a great shot at finally challenging the NFL's football monopoly.

  • Buffett's Berkshire Hathaway was responsible for 1.5% of the taxes paid by corporate America in 2019
    Finance
    Yahoo Finance

    Buffett's Berkshire Hathaway was responsible for 1.5% of the taxes paid by corporate America in 2019

    From Warren Buffett's annual letter to Berkshire Hathaway shareholders.

  • Warren Buffett Flashes ‘Urgent’
    Finance
    Bloomberg

    Warren Buffett Flashes ‘Urgent’

    (Bloomberg Opinion) -- Warren Buffett says he’s in the “urgent zone.” It’s the folksy billionaire’s way of calling himself old. But even as Buffett approaches 90, the spotlight-loving chairman and CEO of Berkshire Hathaway Inc. isn’t ready just yet to talk about who will run his giant company when he

  • Finance
    Bloomberg

    Buffett Chides CEOs Searching for Cocker Spaniels Over Pit Bulls

    (Bloomberg) -- Warren Buffett, who’s served as a director at 21 publicly traded companies over the years, said that too many companies add board members who won’t challenge a chief executive officer’s decisions.“When seeking directors, CEOs don’t look for pit bulls,” Buffett said Saturday in his annual

  • Amex, Facebook, Uber among those raking in millions from 2020 contenders
    Finance
    Yahoo Finance

    Amex, Facebook, Uber among those raking in millions from 2020 contenders

    By the numbers, here is how 2020 contenders are spending their money, and where.

  • Saudi Arabia to Invest $110 Billion in Jafurah Gas Field
    Finance
    Bloomberg

    Saudi Arabia to Invest $110 Billion in Jafurah Gas Field

    (Bloomberg) -- Saudi Arabia plans to invest 412 billion riyals ($110 billion) to develop unconventional natural gas reserves in the eastern Jafurah field, according to the kingdom’s official Saudi Press Agency.Crown Prince Mohammed bin Salman presided over a meeting of the Saudi High Commission for Hydrocarbons

  • Marchers support Assange ahead of London extradition hearing
    Finance
    The Canadian Press

    Marchers support Assange ahead of London extradition hearing

    LONDON — Hundreds of supporters of Julian Assange marched through London on Saturday to pressure the U.K. government into refusing to extradite the WikiLeaks founder to the United States to face spying charges.Famous Britons, including Pink Floyd’s Roger Waters, Pretenders singer Chrissie Hynde and fashion

  • Dwyane Wade on Lebron James: He could play past age 40
    Finance
    Yahoo Finance

    Dwyane Wade on Lebron James: He could play past age 40

    Retirement may not be near for NBA great LeBron James, says close friend Dwyane Wade.

  • Here are Warren Buffett's top 15 stock holdings
    Finance
    Yahoo Finance

    Here are Warren Buffett's top 15 stock holdings

    These are not stock market wagers, Buffett says.

  • Warren Buffett reveals a big change to this year's annual shareholder meeting
    Finance
    Yahoo Finance

    Warren Buffett reveals a big change to this year's annual shareholder meeting

    From Warren Buffett's annual letter to Berkshire Hathaway shareholders.

  • Finance
    Bloomberg

    Berkshire Unit’s Fire Leads to Insurance Loss at, Uh, Berkshire

    (Bloomberg) -- Warren Buffett has built a sprawling $560 billion conglomerate with footholds in insurance, energy and railroads. Berkshire Hathaway Inc.’s reach is so wide, in fact, that its businesses sometimes bump into each other.Buffett, in his annual letter to shareholders, recounted a story about