Canada Markets closed

Jim O'Neill: America doesn't need to be the world leader to prosper

Former Goldman Sachs chief economist Jim O’Neill is famous for his 2001 coining of the term “BRIC,” a framework he created to highlight the rise of Brazil, Russia, India and China in the global system. These developing countries not only have continued to rise, but its members—particularly Russia and China—increasingly dominate the news today.

O’Neill said his idea for the term came to him right after 9/11, after thinking about the implications of the attack beyond the horror.

“It kind of strangely in my head came to me that maybe this means in order for globalization to thrive going forward, it had to be more than just what it appeared to be in the previous twenty years: the never-ending rise of the Americanization of the world as such.”

America doesn’t have to be dominant to prosper

But O’Neill told Yahoo Finance the reality of globalization without ‘Americanization’ isn’t necessarily a negative thing for America, and it could perhaps be a good thing if Americans can set aside their ego.

“If we have a world by the mid-2030s where the combined GDP of the BRIC countries is bigger than the G-7, that is going to be very good for many multinational American countries,” he said, pointing out benefits that include a reduced US trade deficit.

The United Kingdom provides a good framework, O’Neill said, as wealth has grown in the country even as its super power status has diminished. The UK held superpower status into the beginning of the twentieth century. However, fighting two world wars along with the rise of the US and Soviet Union (both hostile to British imperialism) ended its superpower status, which many historians time-peg to the Suez Crisis of 1956.

“Even though Britain no longer has anything like the global presence it did before the Suez crisis, it’s a country that’s seen its wealth triple since then,” O’Neill said. “The US is much more likely to be wealthier for more American people if China, India and others become very big economies in the future irrelevant of whether if they’re bigger than the US or not. I don’t think that’s going to harm the wealth at all of the average American. That is definitely the case of the United Kingdom.”

Meanwhile, President Trump seems to have embraced a nationalist rhetoric, emphasizing country borders and a zero-sum outlook where the rise of other countries (including China) would be negative for the US.

Globalization used to be equated with Americanization, but economist Jim O’Neill that relationship no longer stands (AP Photo/Keith Srakocic)

At the recent G-20 meeting, President Trump said in a speech, “The fundamental question of our time is whether the West has the will to survive. Do we have the confidence in our values to defend them at any cost? Do we have enough respect for our citizens to protect our borders?”

While some, including former Treasury Secretary Larry Summers, have said this confirms the breakdown of international order many have feared since the election, O’Neill said that Trump’s “outdated” rhetoric isn’t necessarily as worrisome as many think.

“It’s forcing other countries to take a bigger leadership role in the world,” O’Neill said, pointing to areas like climate change.

The US could harm itself with trade policy

One area that could be negative for the US when it comes to not embracing globalization is trade.

“This is one of the areas where the US could lose out and therefore harm itself,” O’Neill said.

Indeed, the European Union and Japan just announced a trade deal and Asian countries aim to move forward on the Trans-Pacific Partnership without the United States.

Trump’s message about the ill-effects of globalization has resonated with many Americans, however, and O’Neill said this is just the latest version of pointing-the-finger, which says has “short-term superficial appeal.”

“Trump’s strategy has been a more aggressive version of many repeated temptations like this going back for a good thirty years,” O’Neill said. “I started out in the world of finance in the early 80s when it was very fashionable to blame Japan for all things going wrong in the United States. For the past 15 years, it’s now become China.”

‘No longevity’ to controversial style from Putin

O’Neill added that he’s not worried about a potential rise of Russia, which has become a ‘bad actor’ on the global stage.

“It is also the case that Russia won’t have any chance of becoming as big as the other three countries unless it can do something about its dreadful demographics, its excessive dependency on oil and gas, and its weak productivity…If the Russian economy doesn’t start to improve in coming years, Putin is going to probably run into a serious problem.”

Listen to full podcast

Nicole Sinclair is markets correspondent at Yahoo Finance

Please also see:
Bank of America CEO: Why it matters that 21% of our deposits are made through mobile
Low oil prices are hurting Pepsi’s business
The No. 1 concern for companies during this earnings season
Retail dwarfs coal, and yet Trump has said little about massive job losses

  • TSX falls 0.83 percent
    Finance
    Reuters

    TSX falls 0.83 percent

    NEW YORK (Reuters) - The Toronto Stock Exchange's S&P/TSX fell 127.53 points, or 0.83 percent, to 15,285.17. Leading the index were West Fraser Timber Co Ltd , up 6.5 percent, Alamos Gold Inc , up 6.1 percent, and B2Gold Corp , higher by 3.8 percent. Lagging shares were Aurora Cannabis Inc , down

  • TSX partially rebounds from weak start as the oil prices dip to two-month low
    Finance
    The Canadian Press

    TSX partially rebounds from weak start as the oil prices dip to two-month low

    TORONTO — Canada's main stock index partially rebounded after falling to a six-month low in early trading, while oil prices closed at a two-month low.

  • Trudeau Imposes Carbon Tax, With Rebates, on Four Provinces
    Finance
    Bloomberg

    Trudeau Imposes Carbon Tax, With Rebates, on Four Provinces

    Trudeau announced a plan Tuesday to tax industrial emitters and fuels in holdout provinces. The baseline price on carbon will be C$20 per metric tonne initially, rising to C$50 by 2022. The plan will apply to Ontario, Saskatchewan, Manitoba and New Brunswick.

  • The Rolling Bear Market in U.S. Equities Is Getting Hard to Shake Off
    Finance
    Bloomberg

    The Rolling Bear Market in U.S. Equities Is Getting Hard to Shake Off

    The S&P 500 is down more than 6 percent since its record close in late September while banks, automakers and raw materials suppliers have lost roughly twice as much. While the S&P 500’s current peak-to-trough retreat trails other pullbacks this year, individual stocks are faring worse. Losses were

  • Coalition of consumer groups calls for new code of conduct for telecom sales
    Finance
    The Canadian Press

    Coalition of consumer groups calls for new code of conduct for telecom sales

    Chow also disputed the claim that internal guidelines and rules issued by companies are effective in prohibiting misleading, aggressive and unsuitable sales — saying actual sales practices are at odds with the values expressed by management. "Whether this situation is due to the companies'

  • Finance
    The Canadian Press

    Capital One: 3Q Earnings Snapshot

    MCLEAN, Va. (AP) _ Capital One Financial Corp. (COF) on Tuesday reported third-quarter net income of $1.5 billion.

  • Tesla Skeptic Andrew Left Is Now Long on ‘Proven Hit’ Model 3
    Finance
    Bloomberg

    Tesla Skeptic Andrew Left Is Now Long on ‘Proven Hit’ Model 3

    Citron Research’s Andrew Left, a vocal and long-term Tesla short, said in a report Tuesday that the electric-car maker is snatching customers from BMW, Mercedes, Toyota and Honda. In a Bloomberg Television interview, he said Chief Executive Officer Elon Musk has distracted investors from a company that

  • Saudi crown prince proclaims investment conference despite boycott
    Finance
    Reuters

    Saudi crown prince proclaims investment conference despite boycott

    This year's Future Investment Initiative was overshadowed by the death of the Saudi journalist, a critic of Crown Prince Mohammed bin Salman, who vanished after he entered the country's consulate in Istanbul on Oct 2. A number of Western politicians and global business chiefs stayed away from

  • One-day Toronto strike has 'significant impact' on operations, says Canada Post
    Finance
    The Canadian Press

    One-day Toronto strike has 'significant impact' on operations, says Canada Post

    A 24-hour strike at two of Canada's busiest postal sorting plants Tuesday forced delays in shipments of tens of thousands of letters and parcels across the country as Canada Post employees stepped up pressure to back their contract demands. The one-day job action virtually shut down the Crown corporation

  • Stocks End Lower as Late Rally Falters; Bonds Gain: Markets Wrap
    Finance
    Bloomberg

    Stocks End Lower as Late Rally Falters; Bonds Gain: Markets Wrap

    Treasury yields declined and crude oil tumbled. The S&P 500 pared to 0.6 percent a loss that took it below 2,700 for the first time since July, while the Nasdaq Composite Index flirted with a correction before paring losses. Industrial stocks remained under pressure after disappointing results from

  • Mom and Pop Are Buying the Dip in Stocks While the Pros Stay Put
    Finance
    Bloomberg

    Mom and Pop Are Buying the Dip in Stocks While the Pros Stay Put

    For the third week in a row, individual investors bought stocks while institutional and hedge funds were net sellers, data on client flows compiled by Bank of America showed. Thanks to retail demand, equity buying by all the firm’s clients rose last week to the highest level since late May. Liz Ann

  • Stocks fall, marking twelfth down day out of 14 trading sessions
    Finance
    Yahoo Finance

    Stocks fall, marking twelfth down day out of 14 trading sessions

    US stocks began to recover from sharp intraday declines, but still posted losses at the end of regular trading Tuesday.

  • Why Hydro One (TSX:H) Belongs in Your Portfolio Right Now
    Finance
    The Motley Fool

    Why Hydro One (TSX:H) Belongs in Your Portfolio Right Now

    Hydro One Ltd (TSX:H) continues to offer investors incredible long-term growth prospects and a growing dividend, despite recent concerns raised by consumers and the Ontario government.

  • Short-seller Andrew Left is now long Tesla — but he's making a potentially disastrous mistake (TSLA)
    Finance
    Business Insider

    Short-seller Andrew Left is now long Tesla — but he's making a potentially disastrous mistake (TSLA)

    Former Tesla short Andrew Left has reversed on Tesla and is now long. Unfortunately, he's fallen prey to the erroneous thesis that Tesla is destroying its competition. There is no meaningful competition in the electric-vehicle market, which is globally tiny.

  • Twitter removes accounts linked to Alex Jones, Infowars
    Finance
    The Canadian Press

    Twitter removes accounts linked to Alex Jones, Infowars

    Twitter has removed some accounts thought to be used to circumvent a ban on conspiracy-monger Alex Jones and Infowars, the company said Tuesday. A Twitter spokesman confirmed that the accounts had been removed but provided no additional comment. It was also likely from the start that Jones and his

  • The Latest: Trump says Saudi operation 'worst cover up ever'
    Finance
    The Canadian Press

    The Latest: Trump says Saudi operation 'worst cover up ever'

    Saudi Arabia has claimed Khashoggi, a writer for The Washington Post who wrote critically about Saudi Crown Prince Mohammed bin Salman, died accidentally in a brawl at the Saudi Consulate in Istanbul on Oct. 2.

  • Oil Tumbles 4% as Saudis Pledge to Produce as Much as They Can
    Finance
    Bloomberg

    Oil Tumbles 4% as Saudis Pledge to Produce as Much as They Can

    Futures dropped 4.2 percent in New York. Saudi Arabia, the world’s biggest oil exporter, has boosted production to 10.7 million barrels a day and is nearing an all-time high. Oil stocks were caught up in Tuesday’s broad equities sell-off.

  • Finance
    Bloomberg

    AmEx Says DOJ, Regulators Probing Foreign-Exchange Business

    The company has received subpoenas from the civil and criminal divisions of the DOJ, and inquiries from overseers including the Federal Reserve, it said in a regulatory filing Tuesday. AmEx said it doesn’t expect the matter to have a “material adverse impact” on its business. The company said earlier

  • Americans who don't have a bank account at lowest level ever
    Finance
    The Canadian Press

    Americans who don't have a bank account at lowest level ever

    The percentage of Americans who do not have a bank account fell to a record low last year, the Federal Deposit Insurance Corp. said Tuesday, a sign that the economic fortunes of the country's most vulnerable people continues to improve. In 2017 approximately 6.5 per cent of U.S. households did not

  • Turkish Outrage Over Khashoggi Hints at Changing World Order
    Finance
    Bloomberg

    Turkish Outrage Over Khashoggi Hints at Changing World Order

    Any cover-up of the true authors of such a savage attack “would be an affront to humanity’s conscience,” Turkey’s President Recep Tayyip Erdogan told his parliamentary party on Tuesday. The contrast with U.S. President Donald Trump’s more tepid response -- Trump said Erdogan had been “pretty rough on

  • SoftBank's Son cancels Saudi conference speech: sources
    Finance
    Reuters

    SoftBank's Son cancels Saudi conference speech: sources

    Son's absence from the stage is a marked contrast to last year's inaugural event, where the 61-year-old Japanese entrepreneur was a notable presence, lending credibility to Crown Prince Mohammed bin Salman's efforts to attract foreign investment. Son is in Riyadh this week to meet with high-ranking

  • Privatize Petrobras? Check With Bolsonaro's Generals First
    Finance
    Bloomberg

    Privatize Petrobras? Check With Bolsonaro's Generals First

    The risk for financial markets is if these generals gain the upper hand in an eventual Bolsonaro administration and sideline his top economic adviser who has pushed for privatizations of state-controlled oil producer Petrobras and power generator Eletrobras. Conflicting signals from the campaign have

  • Feds face calls to open Saudi deal after PM says cancelling would cost taxpayers
    Finance
    The Canadian Press

    Feds face calls to open Saudi deal after PM says cancelling would cost taxpayers

    The controversy surrounding Canada's $15-billion deal to sell armoured vehicles to Saudi Arabia got deeper on Tuesday, as Prime Minister Justin Trudeau revealed that taxpayers would pay "significant financial penalties" if the contract was cancelled. The comment came as the federal government

  • U.S. appeals court revives Nestle child slavery lawsuit
    Finance
    Reuters

    U.S. appeals court revives Nestle child slavery lawsuit

    Judges of the 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals in Pasadena, California, said in a unanimous decision that the group could proceed with its claims despite the alleged abuses having occurred overseas. The court did not rule on the merits of the plaintiffs' claims. The plaintiffs, originally from

  • Finance
    The Canadian Press

    Michelin, Manulife Financial announce major expansions in Nova Scotia

    Officials say expansions by two major corporations in Nova Scotia could bring hundreds of new jobs to the province. In separate announcements Tuesday, the province unveiled rebates for Michelin North America (Canada) Inc. and Manulife Financial Corp. Nova Scotia Business Inc., the province's business