Canada Markets close in 3 hrs 52 mins

Which of the Big 5 Banks Performed Best in Q4?

Stephanie Bedard-Chateauneuf

The Big Five banks? earnings season was closed by Bank of Montreal (TSX:BMO)(NYSE:BMO) on December 5. You may wonder which big bank performed best after the fourth quarter round and which one you should buy.

Two out of five beat expectations

Of the five big banks, only two surpassed expectations in terms of quarterly profit: Royal Bank of Canada (TSX:RY)(NYSE:RY) and Canadian Imperial Bank of Commerce (TSX:CM)(NYSE:CM).

The other three banks failed to meet profit expectations. Toronto-Dominion Bank (TSX:TD)(NYSE:TD) and Bank of Nova Scotia (TSX:BNS)(NYSE:BNS) saw their profits rise, while Bank of Montreal?s profits fell.

TD Bank?s adjusted earnings were up 11.5% to $1.36 per share, but missed estimates by $0.03. Bank of Nova Scotia?s adjusted earnings rose 4.4% to $1.65 per share, but missed consensus by $0.01. Bank of Montreal?s earnings fell 7.6% to $1.94 per share on an adjusted basis, while analysts expected a profit of $1.99 per share.

Let?s take a deeper look at RBC and CIBC results to see which one performed best.

Royal Bank of Canada

RBC had a net income of $2.84 billion in the fourth quarter, up 12% compared to the same quarter last year.  Revenue was up 12.3% from $9.4 billion to $10.5 billion.

The largest Canadian bank?s profit reached $1.88 per diluted share, up 14% from a year ago. This profit was driven by strong double-digit growth in personal and commercial banking, wealth management and capital markets.

Adjusted for certain items, RBC?s fourth-quarter earnings per share rose 16.4% to $1.92, while the bank was expected to earn $1.87.

RBC?s personal and commercial banking division net income rose 10% to $1.40 billion. RBC?s wealth management and capital markets divisions saw even bigger jumps in the fourth quarter, with net income of $491 million and $584 million, up 24% and 21%, respectively, from the same period in the previous year.

RBC?s annual net income amounted to $11.5 billion, up 10% from fiscal 2016.

Canadian Imperial Bank of Commerce

CIBC reported a net income of $1.16 billion in the fourth quarter, up 25% from $931 million during the same period last year, which was driven by strong performances across all its divisions. Revenue for the quarter totalled $4.27 billion, up 16% from $3.68 billion in the same period a year ago.

CIBC earned a profit of $2.59 per diluted share, up 11.6% compared to the same quarter in 2016.

The fifth-largest Canadian bank easily beat estimates in the fourth quarter. The bank earned a profit of up 8% to $2.81 per share on an adjusted basis, while analysts expected on average a profit of $2.59.

Profit was boosted by a surge in U.S. profits thanks to the acquisition of PrivateBancorp in June. Profit in the bank?s U.S. division rose 365% to $107 million from $23 million a year earlier.

The largest part of CIBC?s profit came from its Canadian division, where adjusted earnings rose by $63 million year-over-year to $623 million.

For the full year, CIBC earned $4.7 billion, almost 10% higher than in 2016.

Which bank is a better buy?

Based on its latest results, CIBC appears to be the frontrunner, but I?m leaning towards this stock for other reasons as well. CIBC?s stock has a higher dividend yield than RBC at 4.3% versus 3.4%. CIBC?s forward P/E is only 10.1, while RBC?s is higher at 11.9. CIBC has a profit margin of 30.4% and a return on equity of 17.2%, compared to 28.9% and 15.7%, respectively, for RBC.

All of the big banks are financially solid and are great long-term investments, but I think CIBC is a better buy in the short term.

More reading

Fool contributor Stephanie Bedard-Chateauneuf has no position in any stocks mentioned.

  • Stocks Extend Decline; Treasuries, Dollar Advance: Markets Wrap
    Finance
    Bloomberg

    Stocks Extend Decline; Treasuries, Dollar Advance: Markets Wrap

    Weak results from Germany’s SAP and Taiwan Semiconductor dragged American tech indexes lower. Earnings misses from a several U.S. industrial firms and a Bank of America downgrade of the housing sector fueled worries that higher interest rates and the trade war are hitting profits. The weakness in American

  • What to Watch in China GDP Report: Trade, Autos, Manufacturing
    Finance
    Bloomberg

    What to Watch in China GDP Report: Trade, Autos, Manufacturing

    Gross domestic product probably expanded 6.6 percent from a year earlier in the third quarter, according to a Bloomberg survey of economists ahead of the report, due Friday morning in Beijing. Forecasters also expect data on retail sales and fixed-asset investment to show growth held steady in September

  • Market sell-off intensifies after Mnuchin drops out of Saudi conference
    Finance
    Yahoo Finance

    Market sell-off intensifies after Mnuchin drops out of Saudi conference

    All three of the major indices opened lower on Thursday jobless claims fell.

  • Oil dips but pares losses with Wall Street bounce
    Finance
    Reuters

    Oil dips but pares losses with Wall Street bounce

    In early trading, global benchmark Brent crude fell below $79 per barrel, or as much as 1.7 percent the day after a U.S. Energy Department report showed the fourth weekly increase in U.S. crude stocks. Oil prices reversed course as U.S. equities came off session lows. Oil prices remain under pressure

  • The Latest: EU says it will be rigorous with Italy on budget
    Finance
    The Canadian Press

    The Latest: EU says it will be rigorous with Italy on budget

    EU Commission chief Jean-Claude Juncker says the EU has always been generous with Italy when it comes to assessing its budget, but that the latest draft presented this week would be rigorously vetted to see if it meets EU standards. Juncker said after Thursday's summit that some EU leaders had already

  • Warburg Pincus Is Considering $3 Billion Navitas Midstream Sale
    Finance
    Bloomberg

    Warburg Pincus Is Considering $3 Billion Navitas Midstream Sale

    Navitas has hired investment bank Jefferies Financial Group Inc. to run an auction process, said the people, who asked not to be identified because they weren’t authorized to speak publicly. No agreement has been reached and it’s possible Warburg may keep the company. A representative for Navitas didn

  • Finance
    The Canadian Press

    Nebraska's message for tourists? 'It's not for everyone'

    The new sales pitch has a decidedly self-deprecating bent: "Nebraska. The slogan, which the Nebraska Tourism Commission unveiled Wednesday at a Nebraska City conference, will replace the current "Through My Eyes" campaign this spring, commission marketing manager Jenn Gjerde said Thursday

  • Canada drops U.S.-made aluminum-can tariff amid beer can shortage
    Finance
    Reuters

    Canada drops U.S.-made aluminum-can tariff amid beer can shortage

    Canada's move to drop a 10 percent duty on U.S.-made aluminum cans is good news for Canadian beer makers battling a shortage of tall cans, according to brewing industry executives. The aluminum products excluded from tariffs last week include cans that brewers have been struggling to keep in stock

  • Mnuchin Quits Saudi Investor Event With Furor Mounting Over Khashoggi
    Finance
    Bloomberg

    Mnuchin Quits Saudi Investor Event With Furor Mounting Over Khashoggi

    Mnuchin sent a tweet on Thursday saying that after meeting with President Donald Trump and Secretary of State Michael Pompeo he decided not to participate in the Future Investment Initiative, an event organized by Crown Prince Mohammed bin Salman. Mnuchin is visiting several countries in the region

  • The Lunchtime Lowdown - Your midday update for Oct. 18
    News
    Yahoo Canada Original Videos

    The Lunchtime Lowdown - Your midday update for Oct. 18

    Here's what traders are talking about today.

  • Coca-Cola names company veteran Brian Smith chief operating officer
    Finance
    Reuters

    Coca-Cola names company veteran Brian Smith chief operating officer

    Coca-Cola Co on Thursday appointed company veteran Brian Smith as its chief operating officer, a role that has been vacant since former COO James Quincey became chief executive officer last year. Smith, 62, joined the beverage company in 1997 and is currently president of its Europe, Middle East and

  • Finance
    The Canadian Press

    Stocks skid as interest rates rise and earnings disappoint

    U.S. stocks are falling Thursday as interest rates resume their upward climb and several industrial companies post disappointing third-quarter results. Interest rates started rising a day ago after the Federal Reserve released minutes showing that a minority of its leaders think interest rates will

  • Here's everyone who has dropped out of Saudi Arabia's 'Davos of the Middle East'
    Finance
    Yahoo Finance

    Here's everyone who has dropped out of Saudi Arabia's 'Davos of the Middle East'

    Prominent members of the world's business community are dropping out of Saudi Arabia's Future Investment Initiative, commonly known as Davos of the Middle East.

  • Europe's Equity Rebound Turns to Gloom Again, Thanks to the U.S.
    Finance
    Bloomberg

    Europe's Equity Rebound Turns to Gloom Again, Thanks to the U.S.

    (Bloomberg) -- Once again, a promising equity rebound in Europe has been derailed by the U.S. open.

  • Anta Consortium Seeks $4 Billion to Fund Amer Purchase
    Finance
    Bloomberg

    Anta Consortium Seeks $4 Billion to Fund Amer Purchase

    A total loan size of at least 3.5 billion euros could make it the biggest for a Chinese outbound acquisition this year, data compiled by Bloomberg show. The financing would only be finalized if the Anta-led group proceeds to make a binding bid for Amer, according to the people. Anta said last month

  • Blackstone’s Profit Beats Expections as Firm Gathers More Assets
    Finance
    Bloomberg

    Blackstone’s Profit Beats Expections as Firm Gathers More Assets

    Blackstone Group LP brought in $24.1 billion in new capital in the third quarter, helping the largest alternative asset manager beat profit expectations, according to its earnings report Thursday. Key InsightsAs fundraising in the private equity industry slows this year, Blackstone bucked that trend

  • Finance
    The Canadian Press

    The Latest: Fire burning in California gas storage area

    A fire is burning in an underground natural gas storage area in the San Francisco Bay Area and officials are working to empty the natural gas from a nearby Chevron pipeline after thousands of residents were evacuated. Chevron spokesman Cary Wages told reporters Thursday that crews were purging gas from

  • Dollar rides a Fed wave higher; stocks, oil drop
    Finance
    Reuters

    Dollar rides a Fed wave higher; stocks, oil drop

    Stocks, already under pressure from rising borrowing costs, were further weighed by concern over a simmering U.S.-Sino trade war. Shanghai's benchmark index closed at a near four-year low and China's premier warned of risks to the economy. Minutes of the Federal Reserve's latest meeting

  • Wall Street drops after weak industrial earnings, hawkish Fed
    Finance
    Yahoo Finance

    Wall Street drops after weak industrial earnings, hawkish Fed

    Yahoo Finance's Midday Movers provides LIVE market coverage and analysis.

  • SAP plays down margin fears, prioritizes growth: CFO
    Finance
    Reuters

    SAP plays down margin fears, prioritizes growth: CFO

    "In the long term, the cloud is the healthier business model because it is easier to plan, because it has a higher total lifetime value," he said in an interview at SAP's headquarters in Walldorf. "I am very happy with this development and would never try to hold back the cloud business

  • Ex-ESPN President John Skipper: Why DAZN can compete with ESPN
    Finance
    Yahoo Finance

    Ex-ESPN President John Skipper: Why DAZN can compete with ESPN

    DAZN, the UK-based "Netflix of sports," is spending big on boxing to get a foothold in America, starting with combat sports.

  • Quantum Energy Is Weighing Sale of Intensity Midstream
    Finance
    Bloomberg

    Quantum Energy Is Weighing Sale of Intensity Midstream

    Quantum is working with Jefferies Financial Group Inc. on an auction process for the Tulsa, Oklahoma-based company, said the people, who asked not to be identified because they weren’t authorized to speak publicly. Intensity is attracting interest from other private equity and infrastructure firms,

  • MoviePass operations under investigation by New York AG
    Finance
    The Canadian Press

    MoviePass operations under investigation by New York AG

    The company that runs the beleaguered MoviePass discount service for theatre tickets is being investigated by the New York Attorney General on allegations that it misled investors. Helios and Matheson has struggled financially and is facing class action lawsuits filed on behalf of investors claiming

  • Finance
    The Canadian Press

    As Canada legalizes pot, other countries likely to follow

    More than two dozen countries have relaxed their marijuana or other drug laws, and a number could consider legalizing in the not-too-distant future. The South American nation of Uruguay was first to legalize marijuana in 2013. Canada became the second on Wednesday and its size and global standing likely

  • Invesco Bets $5.7 Billion That Active Management Has Future
    Finance
    Bloomberg

    Invesco Bets $5.7 Billion That Active Management Has Future

    Invesco agreed to pay about that amount in a deal with Massachusetts Mutual Life Insurance Co. to acquire its OppenheimerFunds, which specializes in picking stocks and bonds especially in the international arena. At a time when many investors are deserting active funds for products that track indexes