Canada Markets close in 6 hrs 12 mins

Why it matters whether Rosenstein is fired or he resigns

Christina Wilkie

The fate of Deputy Attorney General Rod Rosenstein is reportedly hanging in the balance . As of midday on Monday, it was unclear whether Rosenstein, who oversees major parts of the Justice Department, including the special counsel's Russia probe, would be fired or whether he would resign.

In Rosenstein's particular case, this could make a big difference as to who Trump can select to replace the outgoing appointee as deputy attorney general.

The question of who would oversee the Russia probe is slightly different, however, because Rosenstein has been effectively wearing two hats since Attorney General Jeff Sessions recused himself last year from any role overseeing Robert Mueller's investigation. One hat is that of deputy attorney general. The other hat is that of acting attorney general for the Russia probe, because Rosenstein was acting as a stand-in for Sessions.

Any replacement of Rosenstein by Trump, therefore, would be a replacement of his deputy attorney general position. Not a replacement of the other role, acting attorney general for the Russia probe, which Rosenstein been playing. That hat would go to Solicitor General Noel Francisco, and experts agree that the law gives Trump little control over that aspect of the succession process.

Still, the question of how much control Trump would have in who replaces Rosenstein could have far-reaching implications for the Justice Department. A Rosenstein replacement could take steps to protect the president from investigation, to seal records, withhold funding from Mueller, and otherwise slow the work of the special counsel down to a crawl.

With that in mind, here's why the "fired" vs. "resigned" question could be very important.

The replacement of government appointees is largely governed by the rules set forth in the 1998 Federal Vacancies Reform Act. This law gives the president the authority to temporarily move any one of his Senate-confirmed political appointees into a position that is vacant, provided the person who leave the positions "dies, resigns, or is otherwise unable to perform the functions and duties of the office."

The law specifically does not say "dies, resigns or is fired."

In the case of firings, the federal government has a succession plan, under which temporarily vacant posts are typically filled by a deputy to the person who departs, or by another person who has been confirmed by the Senate within that department. This is in part to make sure that continuity is maintained in agencies with tens of thousands of employees and billion dollar budgets.

But it is also in place, experts say, to preserve the Senate's role in the confirmation process, and to make sure the president can't simply bypass the Senate and fire someone in order to put whomever he or she wants into that position, even if that person has not been confirmed to work in that particular agency.

Trump, however, has challenged this long-held practice. When Veterans Affairs Secretary David Shulkin was ousted earlier this year, Trump quickly named Robert Wilkie, undersecretary for personnel and readiness at the Defense Department, to temporarily fill Shulkin's position.

But according to a lawsuit filed against the Trump administration by veterans advocacy groups in April, Trump broke the law by disregarding the order of succession at the Veterans Affairs Department, and installing Wilkie, who is not related to this reporter, atop the agency.


The plaintiffs in the case argue that because Shulkin did not resign, or die, or become ill – he says he was fired – Trump did not have the authority to choose whomever he wanted to temporarily fill Shulkin's shoes. According to the succession plan of the VA, they argue, Trump was required to name Thomas Bowman, the deputy secretary of the VA, as acting secretary until another VA secretary could be fully confirmed by the Senate.

In Rosenstein's case, the stakes are much, much higher, given that Sessions has recused himself from the Russia probe. Trump has effectively gone to war against his own Justice Department, primarily over the Russia probe, which is run by former FBI director Robert Mueller , but also for what the president sees as a failure by the department to pursue his political enemies.

If Rosenstein were to formally resign, then the Vacancies Act would give Trump broad leeway in appointing Rosenstein's temporary successor. Some fear the president would install a political ally willing to shut down the Mueller probe.

If, however, Rosenstein is fired, then the argument that Trump must follow the federal order of succession becomes significantly stronger.