How much does it cost to raise a child? College may no longer be the biggest expense.
Medora Lee, USA TODAY
Updated 5 min read
Parents spend a lot of time worrying about how they’ll afford college tuition for their kids someday, but a pair of recent surveys show exorbitant college-like costs actually come much earlier in life.
In more than half the states, child care costs more than in-state public college tuition, according to lending platform NetCredit.com. Then, comes the price you pay for independent kids. Teen car ownership now also costs more than in-state tuition at a public university, an analysis by car app Jerry shows.
Everyone already knows raising a child is expensive, but it’s getting even pricier. After two years of elevated inflation, families are feeling pinched more than ever. Overall, for example, parents spend a significant portion of their annual income on child-related expenses. Nationwide, families spend 19% of their annual income on child-rearing expenses, online lending marketplace LendingTree said.
“Ideally, you’d be able to keep child care costs to 10% or less of your total income,” said Matt Schulz, LendingTree's chief credit analyst. “But that’s laughably unrealistic for millions of Americans.”
How expensive is child care?
On average, child care costs $1,031 a year more than public college tuition, NetCredit said.
NetCredit examined the average annual fees paid for public in-state college tuition and the average cost of child care in each state and calculated the difference between the two. Then, it compared these costs to local average salaries to find the affordability of child care and in-state college tuition in every state.
In 28 out of 50 states, child care tops in-state tuition, it said. Hawaii has the largest gap: Annual child care costs a whopping $15,995 more than a year of tuition. New York is a close second with a $15, 951 gap between child care and college costs.
At the other end of the spectrum, Vermont’s annual child care costs were $5,423 less than in-state public college tuition, NetCredit said. That’s followed by South Carolina, a distant second, with child care $3,679 below annual tuition.
How expensive is it for a teenager to own a car?
It costs $11,378 a year for a teen to own and drive a new car, more than the average annual in-state tuition at a four-year public university, estimated at $10,940, Jerry said.
To find this, Jerry used AAA’s driving costs calculator and added the difference ($829) in insurance costs between teen drivers and those over 19 years old. It set annual mileage at 10,000, the choice closest to the 7,200 miles a year driven by the average teen, according to the U.S. Federal Highway Administration.
When comparing increases in tuition and the costs of car ownership, it compared the College Board’s tuition in the 2017-18 academic year with the 2022-23 school year, and car ownership costs from the end of 2018 through July 2023.
Not every teen gets new wheels, of course, but even owning a used car can add up. The annual $10,276 cost to own a five-year-old Toyota Camry exceeds in-state tuition at the flagship public university in 13 states and is just $664 less than the average for all four-year public universities, Jerry said.
At $14.08 per hour – the average wage for fast food workers, lifeguards, retail salespeople, and amusement and recreation attendants – a teen would have to work 49 hours a week over a 15-week summer, or 14 hours every week for a year, to cover the cost of owning and driving a 2018 Toyota, assuming it’s financed, Jerry said.
“No wonder some studies have concluded that shifting economics explains much of the difference in attitudes toward driving and car ownership among Millennials and Gen Z,” wrote Jerry’s Henry Hoenig.
Chevrolet's new industry-first Buckle to Drive feature, embedded in Teen Driver mode, is designed to encourage young drivers to develop safe driving habits.
In 2019, the public policy nonprofit Center for American Progress said about half of U.S. children spend at least some time in a licensed child care facility.
Pair that with the pandemic, which fueled sudden wage growth for child care workers as centers worked to attract and retain workers much like other businesses. As of October 2021, average hourly earnings for child care workers had risen 10.4% to $16.44 from the prior year – on top of already above-average wage growth of 4.3% between September 2019 and September 2020, and much stronger than the 5.8% wage growth for other workers, it said.
In July, annual child care costs were up 6% from a year earlier, around twice the pace of overall inflation of 3.2%, the Bureau of Labor Statistics said.
Blame soaring prices for auto insurance, maintenance and car repairs, vehicle prices and parts, and gasoline. Since 2018, they’ve all risen at least three times faster than tuition at four-year state universities, Jerry said.
And don’t expect car ownership to get much cheaper any time soon. “As interest rates continue to climb, this adds a layer of expense per month that consumers should consider when shopping for their next vehicle,” said Greg Brannon, AAA’s director of automotive research. The Fed has projected it will raise its benchmark, short-term fed funds rate one more time this year by a quarter point to a range of 5.5% to 5.75%.
Medora Lee is a money, markets, and personal finance reporter at USA TODAY. You can reach her at mjlee@usatoday.com and subscribe to our free Daily Money newsletter for personal finance tips and business news every Monday through Friday morning.
