Canada Markets closed

Individual investors jumping in as bull stretches to new highs in late cycle rally

Patti Domm
The emboldened retail investor may be a new catalyst to help take stocks higher.

The emboldened retail investor may be a new catalyst to help take stocks higher — for now.

By any number of measures, the stock market looks to be in great shape — a big healthy bull driven by solid earnings, a growing global economy and the promise of a big tax cut. But strategists also warn the more than 8-1/2 year old rally is in the latter stages of the cycle. That's often when retail investors jump in.

"The level of enthusiasm about the market….has been building. We're seeing more individuals come in," said Liz Ann Sonders, chief investment strategist at Charles Schwab.

Sonders said she's anecdotally seeing signs of more individuals putting money to work in the stock market in the last several months, after years of skepticism and concerns about "every variety of doom and gloom."

She says she is getting fewer investors asking about bubbles or about what's the next shoe to drop.

Whether this improved sentiment leads to a melt up is hard to tell, she said, but stocks could keep going higher into the new year. Earnings in 2018 are expected to grow by 11 percent, but if they falter, that would be a risk, she said.

"I think we're in the latter stages of the economic cycle, which could be very healthy in terms of growth. I think we'll see strong capex. I think ISM, PMIs will stay healthy, but we're getting late in the cycle. We're going to see a pickup in inflation and maybe a tightening of monetary policy," she said.

"I think the later cycle could be a healthy one for the stock market, but it is a cycle where you want to be mindful of risks. I think the next full on bear market is going to be a more traditional bear market," not like the 2008 financial crisis.

The S&P 500 and Nasdaq closed at record highs Friday, and the Dow was near a record.

"I think it's finally starting to suck people in...emotionally and actually it's hard to judge why now all of a sudden, but maybe it's because of how persistent the move has been with so little volatility on the upside and on the downside," Sonders said. "This year has been different. This kind of year pulls people in."

John Velis, macro strategist at State Street Global Markets is also seeing more activity among retail investors, and it's noticeable in allocations to equities and equity-like asset classes. "We're getting close to late cycle behavior," said Velis. Late cycle is evident in "clearly identifiable things like the retail investor getting in toward the end."

But for now, Velis said the trend looks higher. "These kinds of markets can last awhile until something big comes in from the financial sector or the real economy."

For now, the market drivers are positive. "These euphoric periods are born of solid fundamentals," Velis said. "If those fundamentals change, we're going to see that pattern we've seen in the last 10 or 15 years..The question is will it be a big selloff that leads to a recession or is it just a selloff."

The retail investor has been moving back into the market for some time now, but this recent influx, as the market hits new highs, is nothing like the rush of past market peaks.

"I have had the long held view that when this bull market ends, it probably does not end the same euphoric measures as past bull markets," Sonders said.

She added she does not expect to see the same "cult of investors" that epitomized the late 1990s, when investors chased tech stocks higher and talked about stocks with their barbers and taxi drivers.

"It's maybe not a 180 degree turn but maybe a 120 degree turn form the onset of the bull market," she said.

Peter Boockvar, chief market analyst at Lindsey Group, said the retail behavior is not surprising, but there clearly is not the frenzy of past cycles. "Retail generally speaking went through two major bear markets within the last 20 years. They're not going to be showing the same type of exuberance they did in the past."

Equities as a percent of household financial assets is at the highest levels since early 2000, Boockvar said. In part, that has to do with market appreciation. Since bottoming in March 2009, the S&P 500 is up 280 percent. In the past year, the S&P 500 is up 16.3 percent.

"It's typical retail behavior," Boockvar said. People have been selling mutual funds and perhaps buying ETFs, but "the retail client has missed most of the bull market. The fact they coming in now is typical. They're now being forced to pay higher prices, leaving them much less future returns," he said.

Retail brokers have been reporting an influx of accounts. Charles Schwab, in its earnings release, said clients opened more than 100,000 new brokerage accounts a month in the third quarter, making for a record-breaking 10-month streak of new accounts topping 100,000. Its rival, TD Ameritrade, said on its earnings call last month that new accounts, asset inflows and other indicators are at the highest since the financial crisis.

The stock market has gone for 265 sessions without a 3 percent sell off, the longest streak ever, according to LPL Financial.

Sonders said the new money that's coming into the market could be spooked if there's a sell off.

"What happens when you get the first crack? That's probably going to scare a lot of the new money," said Sonders.

But at least heading into the first part of the year, she sees a positive trend. "I think the closer we get to the next recession, the tougher time the market is going to have. I'm not sure we're at that point yet, but we are at the latter stages. We're late cycle for the economy and market. The message for investors is you have to be disciplined. You have to be diversified," she said.




  • Protesters flock to London to back new vote on Brexit
    Finance
    The Canadian Press

    Protesters flock to London to back new vote on Brexit

    Thousands of protesters gathered in central London on Saturday to call for a new referendum on Britain's departure from the European Union. Organizers want the public to have a final say on the government's Brexit deal with the EU, arguing that new facts have come to light about the costs and

  • Mega Millions jackpot surges to $1.6 billion. If you win, here's how to avoid big mistakes
    Finance
    CNBC

    Mega Millions jackpot surges to $1.6 billion. If you win, here's how to avoid big mistakes

    The Mega Millions jackpot now stands at $1.6 billion — the largest in U.S. lottery history — after no one hit all winning numbers in Friday night's drawing.

  • Finance
    Bloomberg

    Putin’s Big Military Buildup Is Behind NATO Lines

    (Bloomberg Opinion) -- Last week I visited Naples and spent time with Jamie Foggo, the four-star admiral in command of NATO’s powerful Joint Forces Command located there. Foggo has responsibility for much of NATO’s European operations and defensive posture from the Balkans to the Black Sea to the Baltics

  • Finance
    Bloomberg

    Italian Populists Struggle to Stay United as Tensions Mount

    “The government will keep going despite the rating agencies, European commissioners and some internal misunderstandings,” Ansa newswire cited Salvini as saying at an event in northern Italy. The populists are under fire from all sides, with EU leaders attacking their budget plans at a summit meeting

  • U.S. Seeks to Phase In Shipping Rules, Sending Refiners Sharply Lower
    Finance
    Bloomberg

    U.S. Seeks to Phase In Shipping Rules, Sending Refiners Sharply Lower

    The Trump administration is seeking to slow the implementation in 2020 of tighter fuel restrictions on the global shipping industry. The move risks alienating an industry that supported Trump, and which stands to gain from the increase in demand for cleaner-burning diesel fuel. U.S. refineries are

  • Finance
    Bloomberg

    Australian Government Loses Majority With Election Defeat

    Independent candidate Kerryn Phelps claimed victory in the electorate of Wentworth with just over 30 percent of the vote counted. The massive swing against the governing Liberal party is a blow to Prime Minister Scott Morrison, weakening his government before national elections due by May. Polls show

  • Chinese premier tells European, Asian leaders Beijing will continue reform
    Finance
    Reuters

    Chinese premier tells European, Asian leaders Beijing will continue reform

    Chinese Premier Li Keqiang said at a meeting between Asian and European leaders in Brussels that China will continue to open up its economy, push forward reforms and improve its business environment, the official Xinhua News Agency reported on Saturday. Li said Asian and European countries need to safeguard

  • Taiwan Independence Supporters Protest in Warning to Tsai
    Finance
    Bloomberg

    Taiwan Independence Supporters Protest in Warning to Tsai

    Unhappy with the president’s moderate stance on Taiwan’s international status, their main demand is for a change to the referendum law to allow the public to vote on Taiwan’s independence. Topics relating to Taiwan’s name, national symbols and constitution are barred under the current law. Since coming

  • Google to charge Android partners up to $40 per device for apps: source
    Finance
    Reuters

    Google to charge Android partners up to $40 per device for apps: source

    (This Oct. 19 story has been refiled to fix wording in fourth paragraph) By Foo Yun Chee and Paresh Dave BRUSSELS/SAN FRANCISCO (Reuters) - Alphabet Inc's Google will charge hardware firms up to $40 per device to use its apps under a new licensing system to replace one that the European Union

  • Italy brushes off downgrade as it plans EU budget response
    Finance
    The Canadian Press

    Italy brushes off downgrade as it plans EU budget response

    Italy's deputy premier is brushing off a ratings downgrade and vowing to forge ahead with the government's rule-busting budget as Italy prepares to respond to European Union concerns about its high deficit targets. International credit rating agency Moody's late Friday downgraded Italy'

  • Khashoggi Crisis Tests Saudi Crown Prince's Firm Grip on Power
    Finance
    Bloomberg

    Khashoggi Crisis Tests Saudi Crown Prince's Firm Grip on Power

    The widening fallout from the death of Jamal Khashoggi, the Washington-based Saudi journalist, inside Saudi Arabia’s consulate in Istanbul has raised questions about whether the crown prince can maintain his grip on all levers of power in the kingdom or if he’ll be checked by his father, or even rivals

  • UBS warns staff over China travel after banker held in Beijing: source
    Finance
    Reuters

    UBS warns staff over China travel after banker held in Beijing: source

    The banker, who is based in Singapore and works in the relationship management team in UBS's wealth management unit, still has her passport, but was asked to remain in China and meet with local authority officials next week, the person said. The purpose of the meeting with authorities is not clear

  • Carney Says Brexit Stress Tests for Banks 'Severe But Plausible’
    Finance
    Bloomberg

    Carney Says Brexit Stress Tests for Banks 'Severe But Plausible’

    Stress tests conducted by the central bank show Britain’s financial system would still have more than adequate capital to maintain lending in the face of multiple headwinds, Carney said in a speech in New York on Friday. The bank has been “preparing for the worst” outcome to the U.K.’s negotiations,

  • Brexit Deadlock May Make ECB Reticence on Risks Hard to Sustain
    Finance
    Bloomberg

    Brexit Deadlock May Make ECB Reticence on Risks Hard to Sustain

    Policy makers have given limited prominence to that risk despite divorce talks between the U.K. and European Union repeatedly stalling before the country’s departure in less than six months. In the economic analysis ECB President Mario Draghi reads out at every decision, it was last specifically cited

  • China's Growth Dragged Down by Construction, Bolstered by Tech
    Finance
    Bloomberg

    China's Growth Dragged Down by Construction, Bolstered by Tech

    Growth in the construction sector slowed to 2.5 percent from a year earlier compared with 4 percent in the previous quarter, the statistics bureau said. The financial sector also grew at a slower pace of 4 percent while information technology continued to expand at a fast clip of 32.8 percent, compared

  • Billionaire Mittal Closer to India Entry as Essar Bid Favored
    Finance
    Bloomberg

    Billionaire Mittal Closer to India Entry as Essar Bid Favored

    Arcelor, controlled by billionaire Lakshmi Mittal, will now begin final negotiations with creditors, the Luxembourg-based producer said in a statement. The move by lenders comes after Arcelor on Wednesday agreed to clear about 74.69 billion rupees ($1 billion) in outstanding dues of two of its group

  • The New Thing in Energy Is Old Pipes
    Finance
    Bloomberg

    The New Thing in Energy Is Old Pipes

    The former Schlumberger Ltd. CEO’s investment vehicle, Sentinel Energy Services Inc., announced Friday it will buy Strike LLC, which specializes in maintaining and repairing pipelines. It is interesting that Gould, having no doubt scanned a wide range of potential targets across the services sector,

  • European Union, Singapore Sign Free-Trade and Investment Pacts
    Finance
    Bloomberg

    European Union, Singapore Sign Free-Trade and Investment Pacts

    The EU and Singapore will remove tariffs, reduce technical barriers, and provide better opportunities in services and government procurement under the deals, the Singapore government said in a statement Friday. The city-state will drop tariffs on all products coming from the European Union. The EU

  • Finance
    Bloomberg

    Vote Again on Brexit

    (The Bloomberg View) -- On Saturday, more than 100,000 people are expected to march through central London to demand a second vote on Brexit. They’re about the only ones talking sense on the matter.

  • Treasury Yields Hammerlocked as Fed Optimism Meets Global Risks
    Finance
    Bloomberg

    Treasury Yields Hammerlocked as Fed Optimism Meets Global Risks

    Minutes from the Fed’s last gathering indicated it’s willing to keep lifting rates even to the point of restricting growth, providing a boost to yields. The coming week will provide insights on the U.S. growth picture from gross domestic product data, and potentially some clues into Fed thinking, with

  • Russian woman charged in first 2018 election meddling case
    Finance
    The Canadian Press

    Russian woman charged in first 2018 election meddling case

    The U.S. accused a Russian woman on Friday of helping oversee the finances of a sweeping, secretive effort to sway American public opinion through social media in the first federal case alleging foreign interference in the 2018 midterm elections. The criminal complaint against Elena Alekseevna Khusyaynova

  • Swiss Re Said to Discuss Investment in Insurer Anbang With China
    Finance
    Bloomberg

    Swiss Re Said to Discuss Investment in Insurer Anbang With China

    Swiss Re is among parties that have been approached as China seeks to find fresh funds to shore up the insurer, according to the people. Since China temporarily seized the acquisitive insurer earlier this year and sentenced its chairman to prison, officials been seeking strategic investors both at home

  • The Latest: Russian woman charged with US election-meddling
    Finance
    The Canadian Press

    The Latest: Russian woman charged with US election-meddling

    A Russian woman has been charged with interfering in American elections, including next month's midterms, through a vast social media effort aimed at trying to sway American public opinion. The Justice Department disclosed the criminal complaint soon after U.S. intelligence agencies said in a joint

  • Saudi Crisis Shows Wall Street Struggle Between Ethics and Cash
    Finance
    Bloomberg

    Saudi Crisis Shows Wall Street Struggle Between Ethics and Cash

    Now Fink’s BlackRock Inc., overseeing more than $6 trillion of other people’s money, is facing a comparable challenge, stuck between conscience and the implacable demands of the bottom line. While BlackRock and the rest of the financial industry have targeted Saudi Arabia as a massive revenue generator

  • Finance
    The Canadian Press

    Telus launches charitable foundation to help vulnerable youth

    Telus Corp. is donating $120 million to launch a foundation that helps vulnerable youth. Telus president Darren Entwistle says the foundation will give grassroots charities grants that can be used to help youth build digital literacy skills, provide basic health care and mental health support to the