Canada Markets closed

German Financial Company Says Screw Stocks, Get a Vintage Car Instead

David Muller
Photo credit: Michael Simari - Car and Driver

From Car and Driver

A bank in southern Germany is suggesting that its well-heeled customers consider adding something far more interesting than stocks and bonds to their investment portfolios: classic cars. Jens Berner, a vintage-car expert at Stuttgart’s Südwestbank, told Bloomberg that such investment advice is being given to customers who have more than the equivalent of $1.2 million in liquid assets. It had its origins after the Great Recession, when collectibles such as art, wine, and classic cars emerged as enticing investment alternatives.

Eyeing the opportunity, Südwestbank launched its own Oldtimer Index (OTX) in 2010. It includes the 20 highest-value cars that are at least 30 years old from Stuttgart-area stalwarts such as Mercedes-Benz and Porsche and Bavaria’s BMW and Audi. The index is calculated once a year by multiplying model prices in Germany’s Motor Klassik magazine and marketplace with registration numbers from Germany’s Federal Motor Transport Authority.

Photo credit: Wikimedia Commons - Car and Driver

The bank started the index at 100 points and backdated it to 2005. It has tripled in value from then to 2018, outpacing the 204 percent rise in Germany’s benchmark DAX stock index, the bank said, noting that Porsche 911 models have fared especially well, jumping 683 percent during that time.

The OTX index is not immune to volatility, however. According to Südwestbank’s website, it posted a significant decline in 2016 but then began ticking back up slightly in the past year. The BMW Isetta was added back to the index this year, and the Mercedes-Benz 300 Adenauer made its debut, thanks to a higher number of registered vehicles and a price increase. At the same time, the Opel Ascona B and Manta B have been dropped from the OTX because their prices haven’t changed, the bank said. The BMW 2000C and 3.0 CSL have also been left off the index after a fall in prices.

Berner told Bloomberg that while classic cars can be a good investment, potential buyers should be wary of counterfeits, already high prices, and a lack of potential buyers. He suggests investing in vintage cars that have a minimum value of about $117,000 so that the costs of insurance, taxes, storage, and maintenance are a smaller portion of total value and said a classic car should make up no more than 10 to 15 percent of an investment portfolio.

You Might Also Like

  • Finance
    Bloomberg

    Trade War Will Produce `No Winners,' China's Xi Tells APEC

    Implementing tariffs and cutting economic ties “is a short-sighted approach and it is doomed to failure,” Xi said at the Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation CEO summit on Saturday in Papua New Guinea. The growing U.S.-China trade dispute is looming large at the APEC summit this weekend in Papua New Guinea

  • PG&E State Review Puts Board Shuffle and Breakup on the Table
    Finance
    Bloomberg

    PG&E State Review Puts Board Shuffle and Breakup on the Table

    “It’s hard to know from outside how far down the structural changes need to go,” California Public Utilities Commission President Michael Picker said in an interview Friday. Authorities are investigating PG&E equipment as a possible cause of the deadly blaze in the Sierra Nevada foothills of Northern

  • Finance
    The Canadian Press

    The Latest: Pence meets Taiwan's delegation at APEC summit

    U.S. Vice-President Mike Pence has met with the head of Taiwan's delegation to an Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation meeting. The U.S. doesn't have diplomatic relations with Taiwan, which China regards as a renegade province, but is obliged by an act of Congress to help with the island's

  • Pence vows no end to tariffs until China bows
    Finance
    Reuters

    Pence vows no end to tariffs until China bows

    The United States will not back down from its trade dispute with China, and might even double its tariffs, unless Beijing bows to U.S. demands, Vice President Mike Pence said on Saturday. In a bluntly worded speech at an Asia Pacific Economic Co-operation (APEC) summit in Papua New Guinea, Pence threw

  • Finance
    Bloomberg

    Can Malaysia Save Democracy?

    The scandal at 1Malaysia Development Bhd., the state investment fund more commonly known as 1MDB, has offered up a classic cast of apparent villains, from former Prime Minister Najib Razak and his wife, accused of siphoning hundreds of millions of dollars from the fund, to the bankers that allegedly

  • Google's new cloud chief has a culture clash ahead of him after 22 years at Oracle
    Finance
    CNBC

    Google's new cloud chief has a culture clash ahead of him after 22 years at Oracle

    Thomas Kurian, who was named the new head of Google's cloud on Friday, is facing an instant culture clash when he starts at the internet company. Google and Oracle, where he spent 22 years, are embroiled in a bitter legal dispute.

  • First African-American top network executive exiting ABC
    Finance
    The Canadian Press

    First African-American top network executive exiting ABC

    ABC Entertainment President Channing Dungey, who created a deep bench of ethnic diversity in the network's shows and fired Roseanne Barr for a racist tweet, will be stepping down. Dungey, who became the first African-American programming chief for a major broadcast network when she was named to

  • North Korea's stable exchange rates confound economists
    Finance
    The Canadian Press

    North Korea's stable exchange rates confound economists

    PYONGYANG, Korea, Democratic People's Republic Of — It's a question that nags at North Korea economy watchers: How has the country been able to maintain stable exchange rates — and avert hyper-inflation — despite intense sanctions, political tensions and a swelling trade imbalance? In a nutshell

  • Finance
    The Canadian Press

    Groups protest plans for possible lease sale in Beaufort

    Federal regulators are preparing an environmental review for a possible offshore lease sale in Alaska's Beaufort Sea and environmental groups are calling foul. The legality of Arctic Ocean offshore lease sales is the subject of a federal lawsuit. Environmental groups say it's irresponsible

  • California utility shares rise as regulator calms investors
    Finance
    The Canadian Press

    California utility shares rise as regulator calms investors

    Shares of Pacific Gas & Electric Co. soared Friday after California's top utility regulator said his agency will help the company deal with potentially crippling liability costs from wildfires. Stock prices soared 36 per cent in midday trading after plunging 60 per cent and losing $15 billion in

  • Finance
    Bloomberg

    Bill Gates-Backed Vegan Burger Maker Beyond Meat Files for IPO

    The company filed with an initial offering size of $100 million, which is a placeholder that’s likely to change. The company’s backers include Microsoft Corp. co-founder Bill Gates and Don Thompson, McDonald’s Corp.’s former chief executive officer. Beyond Meat, based in El Segundo, California, was

  • The Latest: CNN's Acosta returns to White House after ruling
    Finance
    The Canadian Press

    The Latest: CNN's Acosta returns to White House after ruling

    CNN's Jim Acosta is back at the White House after a federal judge ordered the Trump administration to immediately return his press credentials, though a lawsuit over the revocation is continuing. The White House revoked Acosta's credentials last week after he and President Donald Trump tangled

  • Brexiteers Bet the U.K. Can Defy Gravity in Post-Divorce Trade
    Finance
    Bloomberg

    Brexiteers Bet the U.K. Can Defy Gravity in Post-Divorce Trade

    If they get their way on new trade arrangements, they’ll face a test of gravity. Many of those plotting to oust Prime Minister Theresa May also favor reverting to basic World Trade Organization rules -- thereby creating new barriers with Europe -- arguing that it would supercharge economic activity

  • Finance
    The Canadian Press

    Health care, energy companies power US stock market higher

    The market got a brief boost after President Donald Trump expressed optimism that the U.S. and China will reach a deal to resolve their costly trade dispute. The S&P 500 index rose 6.07 points, or 0.2 per cent , to 2,736.27. The Dow Jones Industrial Average gained 123.95 points, or 0.5 per cent , to

  • Oil Short-Selling Continues to Rise With Faith in OPEC Waning
    Finance
    Bloomberg

    Oil Short-Selling Continues to Rise With Faith in OPEC Waning

    The bearish bets jumped 14 percent in the week ended Nov. 13 and have tripled since the end of September, according to data from the U.S. Commodity Futures Trade Commission and ICE Futures Europe on Friday. With oil prices slipping into a bear market, OPEC has promised to do what it takes to cut output

  • Bombardier CEO holds off on a cash request from the government — for now
    Finance
    The Canadian Press

    Bombardier CEO holds off on a cash request from the government — for now

    “I pointed to the CRJ,” CEO Alain Bellemare said in an interview, but added he wasn't ready to comment on potential public support for the ailing jet program. Earlier Friday, Economy and Innovation Minister Pierre Fitzgibbon said his government is open to handing over more cash to the Montreal-based

  • Beloved toy store FAO Schwarz makes its comeback
    Finance
    The Canadian Press

    Beloved toy store FAO Schwarz makes its comeback

    Three years after it closed its beloved toy store on Fifth Avenue, FAO Schwarz has returned to New York. A new FAO opened Friday in Manhattan's Rockefeller Center, about 10 blocks from its former home near Central Park. For more than 150 years, FAO Schwarz was known in New York City for its classy

  • Burke to replace Dungey as ABC Entertainment chief
    Finance
    Reuters

    Burke to replace Dungey as ABC Entertainment chief

    Karey Burke will replace Channing Dungey as president of Walt Disney's ABC Entertainment, the company said on Friday. Burke is currently head of original programming for Disney's cable channel Freeform. Dungey, the first African-American to lead a U.S. broadcast network, will stay through

  • How Moment Helps People Disconnect From Their Phones
    Finance
    Bloomberg

    How Moment Helps People Disconnect From Their Phones

    Nov.16 -- Tim Kendall, chief executive officer of Moment, explains how the company helps combat tech addiction with Bloomberg's Emily Chang on "Bloomberg Technology."

  • Transferwise Benefiting From Brexit Volatility, Co-Founder Hinrikus Says
    Finance
    Bloomberg

    Transferwise Benefiting From Brexit Volatility, Co-Founder Hinrikus Says

    Nov.16 -- Taavet Hinrikus, Transferwise co-founder, discusses how the upheaval around Brexit is impacting the company with Bloomberg's Emily Chang on "Bloomberg Technology."

  • Visa, AmEx, Mastercard Face Brazilian Probe Over Competition Law
    Finance
    Bloomberg

    Visa, AmEx, Mastercard Face Brazilian Probe Over Competition Law

    The Brazilian Administrative Council for Economic Defense, or CADE, is also probing that nation’s Elo network, Visa said Friday in an annual regulatory filing. At issue is a network rule that requires a merchant’s bank to receive certain information from payment facilitators, Visa said. Visa said it

  • How a court record may have revealed the Justice Department's plan for Julian Assange
    Finance
    Yahoo Finance

    How a court record may have revealed the Justice Department's plan for Julian Assange

    A self-professed enthusiast for court records may have revealed the Justice Department’s plans for Wikileaks founder Julian Assange as it continues looking into Russian interference in the 2016 presidential election. 

  • Finance
    Bloomberg

    In Storm-Ravaged U.S. Pacific Islands, Most Still Without Power

    Yutu, the strongest storm to strike the U.S. since 1935, hit the Commonwealth of Northern Mariana Islands on Oct. 25 as a Category 5 storm, chewing through the territory of 55,000 people with 180 mile per hour winds. On Saipan, the larger of the two islands, 75 percent to 85 percent of households still

  • Facebook Under Fire...and on the Defensive
    Finance
    Bloomberg

    Facebook Under Fire...and on the Defensive

    Nov.16 -- Kyle Jensen of the Yale School of Management and Michael Wolf, Activate's chief executive officer, discuss Facebook Inc.'s governance issues and the reports that the social media giant used contractors to retaliate against critics of its privacy practices and efforts to combat Russian

  • Finance
    The Canadian Press

    Don't sign USMCA until LGBTQ language excised, U.S. lawmakers urge Trump

    Canada's fraught new trade pact with the United States and Mexico is facing a new challenge: a group of conservative U.S. lawmakers who say its language on sexual orientation and gender identity is inappropriate and an affront to national sovereignty. In a letter to the White House flagged Friday