China Protesters Demand Back Billions Tied to Suspected Scam
(Bloomberg) -- Hundreds of people took to the streets of the largest city in China’s Henan province this week, calling on authorities to ensure the return of tens of billions of yuan invested in what could be one of the nation’s largest financial scams.
Most Read from Bloomberg
Ukraine Latest: US Slams Putin’s Food-for-Sanctions Relief Plan
Ford Beats Tesla to the Punch With First Electric F-150 Delivery
Top Gun: Maverick's F-18 Flights Cost New Tom Cruise Film $11,374 an Hour
Rare Ship-to-Ship Transfers Keep Oil Moving From Russia to China
Protesters gathered outside the local office of the China Banking and Insurance Regulatory Commission on Monday in Zhengzhou city, carrying signs that read “Return my savings,” according to half a dozen people familiar with the matter, who asked not to be named discussing a sensitive subject. The crowd was dispersed by police and told to return home as soon as possible, the people said.
The protest, unusual for China, followed a freeze in online and mobile cash withdrawal services by four banks in Henan. A subsequent probe found that Henan Xincaifu Group Investment Holding Co., a private investment firm with stakes in all four lenders, colluded with bank employees to illicitly attract public funds via online platforms, the CBIRC said in a written response to questions.
At least tens of billions of yuan in funds were involved, according to a person with direct knowledge of the matter who asked not to be named discussing internal information. The investigation is ongoing and it isn’t clear whether the funds are missing.
“Waiting is very painful since we haven’t received any response on how regulators will deal with our savings,” said Chris, who bought about 400,000 yuan ($59,693) worth of deposit products from one of the banks. “What’s worse, we are quite concerned that our savings would be regarded as illegal investment products.” Chris asked to only be identified by her first name as she fears reprisal for speaking publicly.
The CBIRC said it’s “highly concerned” about the situation and vowed to severely punish any financial crimes.
Consumers should choose official channels for financial business and beware of false propaganda such as “high interest” and “high yield,” the regulator said. Deposit and withdrawal services through branches at the banks -- Yuzhou Xinminsheng Village Bank, Shangcai Huimin County Bank, Zhecheng Huanghuai Community Bank and New Oriental Country Bank of Kaifeng -- are normal, the CBIRC said.
All four banks weren’t immediately available for comment when reached by Bloomberg. Xincaifu Group, which specializes in corporate investment and management, had its business license revoked in February, according to company registration information, and couldn’t be reached for comment.
The incident highlights the risks associated with efforts by the nation’s small lenders to attract funds from outside their limited home bases through partnerships with non-proprietary online platforms. The central bank last year banned lenders from conducting such “innovative” deposit services, citing the need to “safeguard the pockets of ordinary people.”
The protest also risks renewing doubts over the financial strength and corporate governance of nearly 4,000 rural Chinese lenders that collectively control $7 trillion of assets. Confidence in the country’s smaller lenders has waned since 2019, when the government seized a bank for the first time since 1998 and imposed losses on some creditors.
Depositor concerns over the safety of savings at smaller Chinese banks led to several protests in 2020. More recently, the troubles at real estate developer China Evergrande Group have sparked protests in cities across the country.
China’s largest case of financial fraud was in 2016, when the Ezubo P2P lending platform defrauded more than 900,000 people out of the equivalent of $7.6 billion. The firm was fined about 1.8 billion yuan a year later and its owner was sentenced to life imprisonment.
China has disposed of 2.6 trillion yuan worth of bad debt at more than 600 rural banks classified as high-risk over the last few years, and injected 133.4 billion yuan of capital into 289 rural lenders, according to the regulator. Authorities are also considering raising several hundred billion yuan for a stability fund to bail out troubled financial firms.
(Updates with investor comment in the fifth paragraph.)
Most Read from Bloomberg Businessweek
The Tech Rout Isn’t Just Cyclical—It’s Well-Earned, and Overdue
A New Prediction Market Lets Investors Bet Big on Almost Anything
Mark Zuckerberg Is Blowing Up Instagram to Try and Catch TikTok
Deadly Heat in India Is a Warning of Global Catastrophes to Come
©2022 Bloomberg L.P.