Canada markets closed

Canadian Basic Income Of $22,000 A Year Possible With Tax Hikes: Report

(Photo: calvio via Getty Images)

MONTREAL ― A basic income of $22,000 a year to all adult Canadians is financially doable, and would nearly eliminate poverty in the country, a new economic analysis argues ― but not without tax hikes for higher earners and a higher corporate tax rate.

The analysis from the Basic Income Canada Network (BICN) used a simulation database and model from Statistics Canada to predict how three different basic income programs would work. It picked $22,000 as the level because it’s an approximation of the cut-off point for a number of measures of poverty.

It found all three options would virtually eliminate poverty in Canada, with the share of people living below the low income cut-off dropping by as much as 95 per cent, depending on the program type. Families in the bottom 10 per cent of earners would see their disposable incomes jump by 3.5 to 4.5 times current levels. The country would also see an immediate and significant shrinking of the income gap.

The BICN report was released on Thursday.

Watch: Ontario’s basic income pilot project was “a blessing” to these small business owners. Story continues below.

 

Part of the point of the analysis was to address concerns ― even within the basic income movement ― that a workable basic income could be designed, said Sheila Regehr, chair of BICN.

The analysis showed that “there are ways of doing this (that) meet our objectives of reducing poverty, inequality and insecurity,” Regehr said in an interview with HuffPost Canada.

The analysis found a large part of the cost can be covered by shuffling around money from existing federal and provincial programs that would be made redundant by a basic income, such as the Working Income Tax Benefit and the GST/HST credit. 

But it would still require additional revenue to keep it from driving up deficits. 

RELATED

How Basic Income Could Create A Whole New Class Of Entrepreneurs

Professors Around The World Beg Ontario To Revive Basic Income Pilot

Most Canadians, Brits Support Basic Income, But Americans Don’t: Poll

The proposed basic income programs would raise $17.4 billion in revenue through a variety of policies championed by progressive economists as ways to address rising inequality.

This includes hiking the corporate tax rate to 15 per cent from 10 per cent and the small business tax rate to 13.5 per cent from 10.5 per cent. That would return those tax rates to levels they were at earlier this century, before successive rounds of cuts.

And in a move that would ruffle the feathers of higher earners, capital gains ― increases in the value of investments ― “would be treated the same” as income earned from work under the proposed options. Currently, only half the value of a capital gain is taxed as income. People’s principal residences would continue to be exempt.

It would also mean higher income taxes for some. Those in the top 10 per cent of earners ― with an income above $148,000 ― would see their disposable income cut by between 7.2 and 10.2 per cent, depending on the type of basic income. 

No benefits above $60,000

But even some who consider themselves solidly middle earners would see higher taxes, thanks to the elimination of some tax breaks and higher tax brackets. The basic income’s benefit would fade completely at around the $60,000 income mark, and those above it could expect to see some increase in taxes. 

Earners in the $60,000 to $80,000 range would see a reduction in disposable income of between 2.9 and 6.9 per cent, depending on the type of program, the analysis found.

 

Regehr stresses that these are suggestions based on BICN’s principles, which include creating a more equitable tax system. “We’re not saying these are the only sources of revenue,” she said.

For those businesses and capital owners who stand to take a hit to their pocketbooks, she suggests taking the broader view, making an argument many basic income supporters champion: That lifting people out of poverty will create a stronger consumer class, helping businesses.

“It’s to (corporations’) advantage to have a population that’s stable, where people are able to get a good education and to be consumers for the things they are making. There’s a lot of symbiosis in there,” Regehr said.

The analysis shows “we have the money in this country (but) we’re spending it very ineffectively,” she added.

BICN’s three basic income options

All three of these options would involve the tax changes listed above. The costs would be covered through funding from existing programs that are folded into the basic income, and through the tax hikes BICN envisions.

The first option would see everyone aged 18 to 64 receive a basic income that tops up their income so that no one has less than $22,000 per year. As a person’s income grows, the basic income would be scaled back, with recipients losing 40 cents for every additional dollar earned from work. Seniors would retain Old Age Security (OAS) and the General Income Supplement (GIS) ― which are themselves a form of basic income ― while parents would retain the Canada Child Benefit. Cost: $134.45 billion.

The second option is the same as the first, except that it would include seniors, and the OAS and GIS, along with its funding, would be folded into the basic income. The Canada Child Benefit would remain. Annual cost: $187.49 billion.

The third option, sometimes called a “universal demogrant,” would see the government hand out $22,000 to everyone regardless of income. This makes it far and away the most costly option, but much of the cost would be recouped from higher earners through higher income tax brackets. Cost: $637.86 billion.

Love HuffPost? Become a founding member of HuffPost Plus today.

This article originally appeared on HuffPost.

  • How to look great while using your webcam: Tech Support
    Finance
    Yahoo Finance

    How to look great while using your webcam: Tech Support

    Using your webcam to chat with friends and coworkers? Follow these tips to look your best online.

  • Coronavirus response: Bipartisan bill would defer new graduates’ student loans for 3 years
    Finance
    Yahoo Finance

    Coronavirus response: Bipartisan bill would defer new graduates’ student loans for 3 years

    A new bipartisan bill aims to help fresh graduates deal with their student loans by deferring them for up to three years.

  • Finance
    The Canadian Press

    Industry scrambles to stop fatal bird flu in South Carolina

    DES MOINES, Iowa — An infectious and fatal strain of bird flu has been confirmed in a commercial turkey flock in South Carolina, the first case of the more serious strain of the disease in the United States since 2017 and a worrisome development for an industry that was devastated by previous outbreaks.The

  • Italy Premier Conte Extends Nationwide Lockdown to May 3
    Finance
    Bloomberg

    Italy Premier Conte Extends Nationwide Lockdown to May 3

    (Bloomberg) -- Prime Minister Giuseppe Conte extended Italy’s nationwide lockdown until May 3, rejecting pressure from businesses which had been clamoring for a chance to restart activities as containment measures weigh on the economy.The sweeping restrictions, which include a ban on all non-essential

  • Apple, Google to harness phones for virus infection tracking
    Finance
    The Canadian Press

    Apple, Google to harness phones for virus infection tracking

    Apple and Google launched a major joint effort to leverage smartphone technology to contain the COVID-19 pandemic.New software the companies plan to add to phones would make it easier to use Bluetooth wireless technology to track down people for who may have been infected by coronavirus carriers. The

  • Mester Says Fed ‘Likely Not Done’ in Steps to Aid Economy
    Finance
    Bloomberg

    Mester Says Fed ‘Likely Not Done’ in Steps to Aid Economy

    (Bloomberg) -- Federal Reserve Bank of Cleveland President Loretta Mester said the U.S. central bank has probably not reached the end of its emergency actions to shelter the U.S. economy from the coronavirus pandemic.“I know at the Fed, we’re likely not done,” Mester told an on-line discussion Friday

  • Calpers Missed a $1 Billion Payday by Scrapping Market Hedge
    Finance
    Bloomberg

    Calpers Missed a $1 Billion Payday by Scrapping Market Hedge

    (Bloomberg) -- Three years ago, America’s largest pension fund made an unusual investment. It bought so-called tail-risk protection, a kind of insurance against financial catastrophe. In a market meltdown like the one sparked by the coronavirus, the strategy promised a massive payout -- more than $1

  • Trump Vows to ‘Expedite Help’ for Beleaguered U.S. Farmers
    Finance
    Bloomberg

    Trump Vows to ‘Expedite Help’ for Beleaguered U.S. Farmers

    (Bloomberg) -- President Donald Trump said he has asked his agriculture secretary to “use all of the funds and authorities at his disposal,” to aid U.S. farmers, whose financial peril has worsened in the coronavirus pandemic.The administration plans to announce an aid package next week, according to

  • The Latest: Trump bemoans loss of life due to coronavirus
    Finance
    The Canadian Press

    The Latest: Trump bemoans loss of life due to coronavirus

    The Latest on the coronavirus pandemic. The new coronavirus causes mild or moderate symptoms for most people. For some, especially older adults and people with existing health problems, it can cause more severe illness or death.TOP OF THE HOUR— Worldwide coronavirus death toll hits 100,000.—WHO leader

  • Finance
    Bloomberg

    Global Oil Deal Elusive as Saudis Suffer String of Setbacks

    (Bloomberg) -- A global deal to cut oil production and save the market from a coronavirus-induced breakdown proved elusive on Friday as a diplomatic initiative led by Saudi Arabia suffered repeated setbacks.After two days of talks, it remained unclear whether OPEC+ had resolved the differences with Mexico

  • This week in Trumponomics: Maybe Trump is trying to lose
    Finance
    Yahoo Finance

    This week in Trumponomics: Maybe Trump is trying to lose

    Trump is strangely reluctant to use federal powers to combat the coronavirus and stop the recession that threatens his presidency.

  • Finance
    Bloomberg

    Another Tail Risk Hedge Fund Had Eye-Popping March Returns

    (Bloomberg) -- A California hedge fund run by a Pacific Investment Management Co. veteran gained 10-fold in March, rewarding investors who bought its “tail risk” protection against a market collapse.LongTail Alpha’s OneTail Hedgehog Fund II had a return on invested premium of 929% last month as the S

  • Global Deaths Top 100,000; U.K. Fatalities Climb: Virus Update
    Finance
    Bloomberg

    Global Deaths Top 100,000; U.K. Fatalities Climb: Virus Update

    (Bloomberg) -- Deaths worldwide from coronavirus have exceeded 100,000. New York’s daily virus deaths fell slightly after three record-high days. Italy extended its lockdown into May, ignoring pleas from business.France reported four deaths in Covid-19 patients using experimental drugs, including one

  • Companies on the Front Lines of the Coronavirus Fight
    Finance
    Yahoo Finance

    Companies on the Front Lines of the Coronavirus Fight

    Faced with one of the greatest economic challenges ever, U.S. corporations -- both inside and outside of the Healthcare sector -- are reallocating resources in an all-hands battle against COVID-19. Here are some of the companies and what they are doing.

  • Finance
    Bloomberg

    Canada Says Partial Return to Work by Summer Possible at Best

    (Bloomberg) -- Canada may be able to loosen lockdowns and have some sectors return to work by the summer if the nation abides by the tight restrictions currently in place, Prime Minister Justin Trudeau said.The country is currently in the “first and worst phase” of the coronavirus, and modeling shows

  • RCMP says it will enforce the Quarantine Act if people don't self-isolate
    Finance
    The Canadian Press

    RCMP says it will enforce the Quarantine Act if people don't self-isolate

    The RCMP announced new powers aimed at enforcing the Quarantine Act, while Prime Minister Justin Trudeau hinted Friday that rules could be loosened this summer if Canadians act now to contain the spread of COVID-19.The police force says it has been asked to assist in enforcing the act in the midst of

  • US budget deficit totals $743.6 billion over past 6 months
    Finance
    The Canadian Press

    US budget deficit totals $743.6 billion over past 6 months

    WASHINGTON — The federal government's budget deficit for the first half of this budget year totalled $743.6 billion, up 7.6% from last year, and well on its way to topping $1 trillion even before the impacts of the coronavirus were felt.The Treasury Department reported Friday that the deficit from

  • AP Interview: Ex-Tottenham chair Sugar on EPL financial woes
    Finance
    The Canadian Press

    AP Interview: Ex-Tottenham chair Sugar on EPL financial woes

    Three decades after helping to establish what became the world’s richest soccer competition, Alan Sugar assesses the financial landscape with growing concern.“There’s a lot of problems ahead for the Premier League,” the former Tottenham chairman told The Associated Press. “There’s no question of that

  • Food Supply Fears Are Growing as Romania Bans Grain Exports
    Finance
    Bloomberg

    Food Supply Fears Are Growing as Romania Bans Grain Exports

    (Bloomberg) -- Romania became the first country to cut off grain exports during the coronavirus pandemic, a dramatic move that could fan worries about the global food supply.The government passed a decree banning the sale of grain to countries outside the European Union during a state of emergency, which

  • Fitness Startups’ Fates Diverge With Virus Quashing IPO Plans
    Finance
    Bloomberg

    Fitness Startups’ Fates Diverge With Virus Quashing IPO Plans

    (Bloomberg) -- As worldwide lockdowns force avid gym-goers to exercise in their living rooms and boost the profile of in-home workout startups, more traditional fitness companies are feeling the strain.Topgolf International Inc., F45 Training and Xponential Fitness LLC, all of which were making plans

  • Bunnies to the rescue as virus hits Belgian chocolatiers
    Finance
    The Canadian Press

    Bunnies to the rescue as virus hits Belgian chocolatiers

    SINT-PIETERS BRUGGE, Belgium — Master chocolatier Dominique Persoone stood forlorn on his huge workfloor, a faint smell of cocoa lingering amid the idle machinery — in a mere memory of better times.Easter Sunday is normally the most important date on the chocolate makers' calendar. But the coronavirus

  • Boeing delivers 3D-printed face shields and other supplies to combat coronavirus
    Finance
    Yahoo Finance

    Boeing delivers 3D-printed face shields and other supplies to combat coronavirus

    Boeing is using its engineering prowess to create personal protective gear for healthcare workers as the dominant aerospace and defense company’s troubled production lines remain dormant and a majority of its workforce remains at home.

  • Lenders Struggle to Deliver Swift Virus Relief to Small Business
    Finance
    Bloomberg

    Lenders Struggle to Deliver Swift Virus Relief to Small Business

    (Bloomberg) -- Lenders face continued difficulties in issuing much-needed financing under an ambitious $349 billion small business relief effort the Trump administration launched a week ago in response to the coronavirus outbreak, leaving mom-and-pop firms at growing risk of failure.Banks have been intermittently

  • Delta Cut to Junk by Fitch as 35,000 Workers Take Leave
    Finance
    Bloomberg

    Delta Cut to Junk by Fitch as 35,000 Workers Take Leave

    (Bloomberg) -- Delta Air Lines Inc. was cut to junk at Fitch Ratings as part of a general downgrade of the U.S. airline industry and its ability to service debt. The assessment adds urgency to the Trump administration’s desire to save the industry.Fitch on Friday lowered its rating on Delta’s debt to

  • Canadian Stocks See Biggest Weekly Gain Since 2009
    Finance
    Bloomberg

    Canadian Stocks See Biggest Weekly Gain Since 2009

    (Bloomberg) -- Canada shares rose on Thursday, capping the biggest one-week advance since January 2009 despite a record plunge in employment in the country and another surge in jobless claims in the U.S.Investors focused instead on another dose of economic support south of the border.The S&P/TSX Composite