Wed, 16 May, 2012, 2:06 PM EDT - Canadian Markets close in 1 hr 54 mins

The reason more Canadians don’t contribute to RRSPs

As the Feb. 29th RRSP deadline inches closer, a recent Scotiabank investment poll finds only two in five Canadians (39 per cent) say they plan to contribute to an RRSP for the 2011 tax season.

Among those who have thought about investing more often in their RRSP than they currently do, affordability (61 per cent) is the top reason for not contributing more often.

MORE RELATED TO THIS STORY
Why you should pay into your RRSP this year
How much should you invest in your RRSP?
Six reasons to avoid RRSP loans

Mike Henry, senior vice-president of Retail Payments, Deposits and Lending, Scotiabank in Toronto, says living in challenging financial times is all the more reason to speak to a financial advisor about how to find a way to build retirement savings.

"Our recent poll shows only two in five Canadians are planning to contribute to an RRSP for the 2011 tax season. We don't want to see people allow this savings opportunity to pass them by," he says. "Speak to an advisor. Find a way to balance things and take advantage of opportunities that RRSPs and TFSAs (tax free savings accounts) provide."

However, only 46 per cent of those polled reported having a financial advisor. When it comes to planning, 32 per cent of Canadians reported having a written financial plan and 39 per cent said it would be easier to save and invest with a five-year goal in mind rather than a long-term goal. Three in five (58 per cent) said they would be interested in a five-year plan.

"Canadians can sometimes be intimidated when it comes to speaking to a financial advisor and working on a financial plan," Henry says. "What Scotiabank wants to tell people is there's not a lot to it. It really as simple as sitting down with someone and talking about what things you're trying to accomplish financially.

"We recognize the challenges associated with trying to balance the need to live for today while saving for the future. Having a plan is an important key to doing that."

Meanwhile, for investors looking to minimize their exposure to market ups and downs, they may want to review the asset allocation in their RRSPs.

"We live in uncertain times and we definitely see people have some concerns about the economic volatility that's out there. The key to handling that is to understand what your time horizon is and what you're saving and investing for," he tells Yahoo! Canada Finance. "So if you have a long time horizon and if you've got an appropriate asset allocation for your investment portfolio, those are the keys to managing that volatility.

"To put it plainly: Invest early, invest regularly, and stay invested."

Interestingly, among RRSP holders, half (51 per cent) have thought about contributing more to their RRSP than they do now, unchanged from a year ago.

"Different investments behave differently and they have different returns," he continues. "Ensure you're comfortable with what you've got . . . ensure you've safe, secure investments in maybe GICs or high-interest savings accounts but then you want to make sure you've got some things that are a little more growth-oriented like different types of mutual funds."

Henry adds Scotiabank has seen a lot of growth in TFSAs (48 per cent of Canadians have a TFSA, according to the survey).

"It's up by about a third (from last year) so while we see 60 per cent of Canadians with an RRSP, 48 per cent have a tax free savings account and at the rate its growing those numbers should start to catch up," he says. "Only about 35 per cent of Canadians have both. The thing about TFSAs is you're contributing money that's already been taxed, so you're not taxed on it again. Anything you put in there grows tax-free."

Moreover, people are starting to use TFSAs as part of a longer-term investment strategy.

"The types of investments people are putting in their tax free savings accounts are starting to shift a little. Initially, people were holding mostly cash and it looked as thought it was being used as a bit of a rainy day fund," he notes. "Increasingly we're seeing people invest in mutual funds and other things that have a longer-term orientation. That suggests they're making the TFSA as part of a broader, longer-term strategy."

The survey also finds:

*Most Canadians say they have an RRSP (60 per cent), a drop from 79 per cent last year.

*More men (42 per cent) than women (35 per cent) plan to contribute to their RRSP for the 2011 tax year, while those aged 35-54 years lead in the age category (52 per cent) compared to those aged 18-34 (41 per cent) and 55 and over (21 per cent).

*Only three-in-10 (29 per cent) have set up automatic transfers or deposits into an investment plan (down from 34 per cent in 2010).
-30-

 

92 comments

  • Rual  •  Calgary, Alberta  •  3 months ago
    What is this garbage? How can you right an article about savings and not mention Canadians are at their highest levels of debt ever (~150%?). Pretty hard to save when you owe money (to the bank). The article is titled, 'The reason more canadians dont contribute to RRSP's'. The only thing written to answer that question is. 'Among those who have thought about investing more often in their RRSP than they currently do, affordability (61 per cent) is the top reason for not contributing more often.'

    Then you go on to mention all the great products you can buy through the banks. Hmmmm......(owe money to the banks already, why not pay them more with RRSP, and TFSA fees.) Kind of makes you wonder what the purpose of this article was.
    • Pinkgirl 3 months ago
      Yeah but it's Canadian's own fault in getting into debt in the first place. People dont want to save anymore...everyone wants the Iphone ...ipad....best car ...cause they think they need to show off or something... Drives me crazy all the unneccessary spending only for show.
    • K Cass 3 months ago
      Its a necessary evil, all this unnecessary spending keeps you and I employed...if every one stopped spending and only saved we be worse off than the U.S. Save YES but money still needs to flow or else the economy stops.
    • Samuel 3 months ago
      Let guys with RRSP and over 65 to spend the money to buy them.
  • Peter  •  3 months ago
    It's because the average Canadian only gets the high school grad who has taken the two hour Bank financial training course to help them, they are there just to generate fee income for the bank. The Banks experienced guys are saved for the bigger money. You spend a weekend reading up on home finance, you'll already be ahead of the first line advisors they give you, unless you have a fat account at the bank already. Do a Goog for "South Park and it's gone" and watch hehe.
  • Wayne  •  Oshawa, Ontario  •  3 months ago
    A lot of people are working for less, if working at all, and just trying to cover the basics. Is there really any question here as to why contributions are down ! DUH.
    • Pinkgirl 3 months ago
      yeah but I bet you have an IPhone...so your good till you retire.
    • Grams 3 months ago
      What does having an IPhone have to do with not wanting to invest in an RRSP?
    • Samuel 3 months ago
      If you forget the IPhone, buy a cheap phone and it can do three quarter of the jobs that the Iphone can do and also save on monthly charge on cheap phone. By the end of the year you properly save enough money to contribute to the maximum to your RRSP or your TSFA. Understand Grams.
  • Red  •  Michipicoten, Ontario  •  3 months ago
    Pay off your debts first. Having a large mortgage and putting money into an RRSP is dumb. Calculate the interest that you are paying on the mortgage vs the interest that you are getting on your RRSP and you have the answer. Another simple indicator that RRSP's are not a good option is that the big banks are pushing them.
  • Wai Y.  •  3 months ago
    First time home buyers, you want to buy RRSPs. I took out $20k from my RRSP to buy my first house. Over 3yrs, it only cost me $14k since the gov't gave me back $6k. I would have to make about $27k to save $20k after taxes for a down payment. Yes I have to pay back the RRSP account but over 15 yrs. By the way, I have $145k in equity from this house I bought just before the housing boom. Best investment I ever made so far!
    • Rob S 3 months ago
      You could have also taken out an investment loan. written off the interest payments/as a substitute to paying back the rrsp. invest the loan for 20 years. payback the loan and end up with. with an additional 100k in your pocket.

      Rob stinson , investors group, 9054348400 ext 571 if you're interested about hearing more.
    • a yahoo user 3 months ago
      Rob, that of course assumes a rather generous rate of return on the investment made with the loan. BTW, you left out some rather important facts
  • realcanadian  •  Chatham-Kent, Ontario  •  3 months ago
    I am still trying to recover from 2008, my horizon is getting closer and I am still not back to where I was then
    • malinamanito 3 months ago
      i wouldn't have recovered from the financial mess i made in 2008 if foreign relatives didn't bail me out . . . around 200K down the drain in that year alone
  • Don  •  Montreal, Quebec  •  3 months ago
    MAYBE if we were being paid decent salaries, and not being over taxed constantly we would have some money to put into the RRSP, and TFSA.
    • rick the **** 3 months ago
      So what do you think your worth don ? $84 and hr im sure right ? Wish we all had your dreams on what we should be paid but unfortunately we live in a real world not make believe.
    • Don 3 months ago
      Not at all Rick. However I do know that most people are underpaid today. I also know that I live in the most heavily taxed area of North America, and the government wastes more money on stupidity.
  • Veralynn  •  St Paul, Alberta  •  3 months ago
    hard to save when you have no extra income, is it not better to eat today than try to save for tommorrow, might not be to many tommorrows
  • Cesca  •  3 months ago
    Sure Harper - we will invest - as soon as you start getting us JOBS to work in with decent wages and salaries that pay us enough money to live on, pay all our debts, pay for food and then have some money left over TO INVEST.
    And dont forget that those who are on welfare - especially those on a disability - are NOT permiitted to have a RRSP acount. If they do have an RRSP account when they apply for disability - then they are REQUIRED to empty that RRSP account and live off those savings first before they get the disability - so whats the point of saving?
  • panidatec  •  3 months ago
    Oh look, another advertisement for banks disguised as a legitimate article.

    Truth is banks want Canadians to set up RRSP's which in turn will give Canadians virtually nothing in growth

    Said non growth will then result in the bank's upper management putting insane amounts of money into their own pockets.

    A safe deposit box or tin can buried in your back yard is the best investment for your money and has less risk than what your so called investment advisor is telling you to do.

    Otherwise, if you must then it's TFSA all the way.
  • KARLITO  •  Ottawa, Ontario  •  3 months ago
    several years ago i put money into an RRSP. i was not given details on exactly how it works or maybe i didn't ask the right questions, but after all was said and done i lost over 25% of my money. i was pissed that i put money into something i was lead to believe was safe and it wasn't. i took my money out at another loss because of taxes. never again. i read that last year the average RRSP holder lost on average $5000. too damn risky.
  • Tek Heretik  •  Brampton, Ontario  •  3 months ago
    Because they are taxed to death and don't have the extra money?
  • pinky  •  Winnipeg, Manitoba  •  3 months ago
    I heard bad raps about RRSPs.
  • Lark  •  3 months ago
    Another reason is that banks eat up so much of the gains in fees that it hardly makes sense. The only people that show true gains are those that want a potfolio worth between $500,000 and $1 Million which would include, what, about 1% of the population.
  • bill  •  Montreal, Quebec  •  3 months ago
    RRSP's at 1% or 1.5% plus fees for a $150.00 interest a year, I'll be rich in no time, not too good, i would suggest buy your self a piece of Land,a home, best investment on the long run, BEST OF LUCK TO YOU ALL
  • salvatore  •  3 months ago
    your better off investing in buying and selling homes..i regret having rrsp..if i take it out your taxed,,than your taxed again at tax time..twice taxed..buy an investment property rent it or sell it later..more profit in your hands not HARPERS.....
  • A Yahoo! User  •  Mississauga, Ontario  •  3 months ago
    We are paid 1990 salaries in 2012, there's so much left over I'll find a way to put some in RRSP...yeah right!
  • Bob  •  3 months ago
    Some of us have money to invest, but why would you at this point? There is no indication that the markets are anywhere near bottom. Stay out of debt and get that mortgage paid off first.
  • al  •  London, Ontario  •  3 months ago
    We can't save because our children have gotten use to eating and having a roof over their head. Taxes that are taken from us, only to be wasted by our governments, over 75% of the time, make it so that a close to minimum wage earner, can not get ahead. Utility bills, etc that are taxed, insurance, property tax, food,soap, clothes, income tax, licence fees, school fees,drugs, dentist.....our nation is going backwards for the common man.
  • matty  •  Kitchener, Ontario  •  3 months ago
    Did it for quite some time and they lied about what it would earn and I wont ever contribute again. Just a waste of money. I cant touch now till retirement which they will raise the age so I cant touch it even longer..